Key Lime Pie Ice Cream Sandwiches

There’s this new invention called facebook.

Have you heard of it?

People say it’s taking the internet by storm.



There’s also this new bonus to facebook too, that I’m not sure you’ve heard about.

No, it’s not that dumb timeline.  That’s just stupid.

It’s the super hero powers that you can get by using it.

Actually it’s one super hero power, specifically.

It’s called bravery.

I’ve honestly never seen anything like it.


I mean, in real life you would never have the courage to legitimately stalk people from your past.  That would require a lot of effort, honestly.  The black clothes, the ski-mask, the potential jail time.  Really, who’s gonna go to all the trouble?  Enter, facebook bravery.

What about the games?  I mean really?  Creating your own city or farm or pet hotel…it’s time consuming.  Would you ever, before facebook, think it was cool to ask your friend to harvest your corn for you?  Kind of presumptuous, if you ask me.  And really, what would your 2002 self say if you were to tell him/her that you would be spending hours building a virtual city online?  Really…I want your honest answer on that.  Not judging here, just observing.  Luckily you have facebook bravery to unabashedly ask your friends to become a virtual neighbor and do some of the heavy lifting for you.  It takes a village.

But when people get to be their most super-heroish is when they leave comments on your wall, or personal page that basically would get them punched in the face in real life.   That’s my most favorite.  I just imagine people sitting behind their desk with a giant “H” embroidered on their shirt typing away.

Don’t get me wrong, I get facebook powers from time to time.  Not too long ago I posted a picture on my wall of a bumper sticker that I thought was inappropriate and people lost their shizz. The thing is, I fancy myself a middleman.  Just bringing the news to the people.  I’m a giver like that…like a cookie-making Walter Cronkite.

And it’s pretty great to have a different opinion.  I’m open to it.  Just don’t let that super power take you over to the dark side…because unless you’re James Earl Jones, it’s not a good look.


So in efforts to solidify our friendship I decided to make you ice cream sandwiches.  And not just any ice cream sandwich.  Key Lime ones.

Don’t hate, appreciate.

Key Lime Pie Ice Cream Sandwiches.


What’s great about these is you all you need is a mixer and a freezer.  Well, and all the ingredients…and a spoon…and some time…

You mix up your ice cream/key lime filling, which is super easy.  Heavy cream, Key Lime juice, sweetened condensed milk, sugar…it just keeps getting better doesn’t it?

The consistency will look like this:

Pour that into a plastic container and freeze it for 5-6 hours.

At that point it will be almost frozen, but still spreadable.

If you forget it and leave it in longer, it’s not a problem, just let it sit on the counter until it warms up to a spreadable consistency.

Then assemble your ice cream sandwiches using graham crackers!

You’ll use about 1/4 cup of ice cream on each…

Top the ice cream with another graham cracker and then you can individually wrap them in cling wrap and freeze until they are completely firm, about another hour or so.

You can make these days in advance, which is pretty awesome.

Trust me, these are amazing.

Here’s some more Key Lime yumminess from around the internet:

Key Lime Fudge

Key Lime Pie Ice Cream

Key Lime Pie Bars

Chocolate Key Lime Pie Cups


Key Lime Pie Ice Cream Sandwiches

  • Author:


makes approx 12 ice cream sandwiches


  • 3 cups heavy whipping cream, separated
  • 1/2 cup sugar
  • 1 (14 oz) can sweetened condensed milk
  • 3/4 cup Key Lime juice
  • 1 Tbsp Lime zest
  • approx 12 full graham crackers, broken in half to create 12 sandwiches


  1. In stand mixer with whisk attachment whip 2 cups heavy cream and sugar until stiff peaks form, approx 2 minutes.
  2. Turn speed to low and pour in sweetened condensed milk. Turn speed up to medium high and beat 1 minute.
  3. Finally add lime juice, remaining cup of cream and and zest and beat approx 1 more minute on medium-high.
  4. Pour mixture into freezer-safe container and freeze for 5-6 hours until almost frozen.
  5. Spread about 1/4 cup mixture on top of 1 graham cracker at a time, topping with the other half of the cracker. Wrap in cling wrap and put back in freezer. Repeat process until all sandwiches are made.
  6. Freeze 2 hours more, or overnight.
  7. Serve frozen


You don’t have to individually wrap each sandwich, you could store them together in a large container, if desired.
If you make the ice cream a day ahead leave on counter until it’s softened enough to spread on the graham crackers. Do not microwave.


Leave a Reply

46 Comments on "Key Lime Pie Ice Cream Sandwiches"

Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Amy @ FragrantVanillaCake

These sound delicious! I absolutely love the idea :)! So perfect for the warm months ahead, and a nice twist on a classic ;)!

Party Box Design


Hannah at FleurDeLicious

These look fabulous and so refreshing! Love that you don’t need an ice cream maker. Think I’ll make these for my mom, she loves any and all things key lime.

Georganne (LilaLoa)

THESE are definitely going to happen at my house. I’ve been hoarding condensed milk for ages and I think it’s time that I finally just open them up and…EAT THEM.

PS — You are probably going to look back at this spring as “The Spring of the Bumper Sticker.” Pretty sure you won’t be forgetting THAT any time soon. That was kind of crazy. I still think about it. But in a way that makes me like you…not in a “brave” kind of way.

Heather (Heather

hold the phone…other people know about facebook too?! 🙂

these look AMAZING…perfect for warm weather!

Cookbook Queen

Facebook bravery is my favorite. It’s like a time warp where no one is responsible for what they say or do.

Also, where were these ice cream sandwiches when you visited me? I guess I have to make them myself.

Lizy b

These look dreamy!!

Katrina @ Warm Vanilla Sugar

Oh my word! These are lovely!


Though I will never admit this to any of my boyfriends, ex- or present, facebook stalking is one of my favorite pastimes! It’s the best. Really. But if people put information on there, they’re just asking for it to be stalked.

Key lime is one of the loves of my life. This ice cream could be dangerous.

Ashley @ Kitchen Meets Girl

These look wonderful! And I love that it is sandwiched between graham crackers. YUM.

Aimee @ ShugarySweets

Mmmm, after a warm day like today this would be perfect!

Debby Pucci

I wish I had this for dessert tonight!


We love key lime! Josh made a key lime pie today! Wish we had your ice cream to go with it!

Averie @ Averie Cooks

Key lime pie is fantastic stuff and love that you didn’t mess with the whole pie and just made them sandwich style…so good looking!


Such a perfect treat for spring and summer! Love key lime:)
Hmmm, somehow I guess I missed the bumper sticker deal.

Lauren at Keep It Sweet

These are fantastic! Ice cream portion control… although I’m sure I’d eat a bazillion of them:-)

Jessica @ How Sweet

o… m… g… YES. except i think i need to use cookies.


Facebook is zee Devil…that said, I’m going to have to go look at the bumper sticker incident, or I’d it an incident at all? Better go check!


My Facebook hero powers BURNED OUT!!! I looked and my hero vision saw nothing…prolly not missing anything. I have a feeling I’ve got a few emails that pretty much say what yours did, lol…or cry, depending on the day!


I just found your blog and added you to my reader after just this post. I feel like I could write a book about the wonder that is FB stalking. I gossip about FB “friends” like I just saw them last week, even though it’s been 10 (15) years.

Plus. I really love Key Lime anything. Based on this one post, you’re my new favorite!


Key lime pie is one of my all-time favorites – and this makes is even better!!

the wanna be country girl

Wow! those look amazing. What a great Summer-time treat, can’t wait to give them a try.

sue @ Cakeballs, cookies and mor

well they sound great, but I want to see the bumper sticker too!

Lynna H.

easy & amazing? LOVE THE IDEA!


I love this recipe, I am all about quick,easy and tasty ideas…. These look amazing

I just hippity hopped on over from from which I had come from somewhere else following a yummy cookie post on FB ( some lavender beautiful piece of artwork cookie). Love the internet and all the yummy goodness you can follow around from one post to another till you’re lost and can’t remember where you came from and where that other yummy goodness was and the back space doesn’t always bring you back either….. Love your post and sentiments on FB. lol and I especially love key lime! ( that’s a lot of love) Hope to make these as… Read more »

These look mouth wateringly good! I’ve nominated you for The Versatile Blogger Award –

Robin @ Bird On A Cake

Oooh, I love anything with key lime juice! Making ice cream sandwiches with it sounds divine! Here is my key lime cake recipe…told you I loved it. :0)

Heidi BundlesOf Hugs

Oh boy these looks amazing and way too easy to not make! Yum 🙂

Karen @ Sugartown Sweets

I must make these for my daughter’s birthday! She loves key lime..and these look fabulous!

Debra Kapellakis

mmmmm… thank you from my kids and me for a new Summer treat

Jay Sumilang

These cookies and cups recipes looks awesome as well as the photos. Can we look forward to more of your marvelous recipes?

Amazing site, thanks for sharing!


wow this looks amazing!

Living The Sweet Life

Yum!! This would be perfect when it’s scortching hot outside, I may have to do a taste test before hand though 😉

Erin @ Dinners, Dishes, and Desserts

It is amazing what people will say and do on facebook, but would never do in real life! Hopefully these sandwiches can bring peace to social media!


Liking these my friend! Thinking these would be perfect make-aheads for the next kids party.

Tara @

I am not a fruit or tart dessert type- I love me some chocolate…however, key limepie reminds me of my Gram. She always ordered it and made me try it while we were in Florida together years ago…it really is tasty! I wish I was a baker!

My Little Otter

What I’ve “enjoyed” about FacePage (as my Dad calls it) is that you can have a first row seat at watching grown women’s eating disorders/food issues/ compulsive exercising up close. Its like high school all over again– just with more tagging.

bridget {bake at 350}

Love, love, LOVE Key Lime. Love. And, yeah, you seem to get the FB crazies on your page. (You know I just jinxed myself there, right?!?) I’m off to look for this bumper sticker. Better put on my cape…

Ida Pletz
I love Key Lime anything yummm. I make something similar with sugar free jello, sugare free cool whip and low fat graham crackers and yougurt. I mix this up put it in a 11×7 paper cover with saran wrap and freeze. You need 12 crackers gently cut in 1/2 nd you cut the key lime mixture into 12 squares and fill between the two crackers. I wrap them individually and keep in the freezer. You can mix your yougurt and sugar free jello flavors and this is a great low cal treat. 1 box of sugar free jello, 1/4 cup… Read more »

Oh. My. Gosh. I cannot wait to make these in the summer! I just stumbled on your site tonight and this was one of the first recipes I saw, which made me totally excited!

Erika Hennings

After having saved this recipe for over a year I FINALLY made it! Next time I’m going to freeze the ice cream in a glass pan so I can slice the correct shapes for the graham crackers. 🙂


I have all the ingredients ready to make this! Do you think I can make this recipe using an ice cream maker instead, without whipping the cream?


[…] Key Lime Pie Ice Cream Sandwiches […]