Peppermint Patty Chocolate Cookie Sandwiches

So sometimes I have these dreams where I wake up yelling like a lunatic and jumping on top of my husband to save me.  Happens like twice a year.

My husband is not a fan.

In the past I’ve sworn there was a scary murderer crouching on the ground next to my bed…

Another time it was a scary ghost-man floating above my bed, about to kill me.  You know, just floating there.


Then there was that time an older, stately gentleman wearing a dusty blue sweatshirt stood at the end of my bed shaking his head at me. He was probably going to kill me.


I think my subconscious is telling me that I am scared of ghost-men murderers.

Seems valid.


Anyway, I had one of these dreams the other night…but I am happy to say that the cycle has been broken.  I did not dream of a scary murder-man.  Nope.  I woke up screaming and jumping on my husband because a scary 8 inch spider-ghost jumped on my bed…

and was probably going to murder me.


So yeah, I think I am scared of being murdered, by man or spider.


So after I realized the spider was a figment of my imagination, most likely being sparked by watching Arachnophobia with my kids (which, btw, I THOUGHT was a comedy), I laid awake in my bed for a while.


So these cookies are something I thought up while recovering from almost being murdered by a ghost-spider.



Peppermint Patty Chocolate Cookie Sandwiches
PhotobucketThese cookies are totally easy…

They are based on these cookies I did a while back. So this latest version was a total no-brainer.


I started with my favorite cocoa powder, Hershey’s Special Dark.  You certainly don’t have to use the dark cocoa powder, but it really is great in these cookies!


I adapted this cookie recipe from Hershey’s Cookie HQ…with only a few small alterations.


Sift that together with your other dry ingredients…

Photobucket Once you have your batter made, drop it in 2 teaspoon sized portions on a parchment lined baking sheet…

I formed mine into little balls, but you don’t have to.  I just wanted them to all bake the same shape.

Let them cool on your baking sheet for about 3 minutes…

PhotobucketAnd then get your York Peppermint Patties ready…


While the cookies are still warm, but not hot, sandwich a Patty in between two cookies…


The warm cookie will melt the chocolate of the patty enough to stick to the cookies, creating a yummy filling!

These are the perfect cookie for the holidays or a cookie swap!



Peppermint Patty Chocolate Cookie Sandwiches
Makes approx 24 cookie sandwiches
  • 1 cup butter, room temperature
  • ¾ cup light brown sugar
  • ¾ cup granulated sugar
  • 2 tsp vanilla
  • 2 eggs
  • 2⅓ cup flour
  • ⅓ cup Hershey's Special Dark Cocoa Powder
  • 1 tsp baking soda
  • 1 tsp salt
  • 2 cups mini chocolate chips
  • approx 24 York Peppermint Patties
  1. Preheat oven to 350°
  2. In a large mixing bowl cream together your butter and both sugars until light and fluffy, about 2 minutes. Add in vanilla and both eggs and stir until combined and smooth, about 1 more minute.
  3. IN a separate bowl sift together flour, cocoa powder, baking soda and salt.
  4. Slowly add into butter mixture, Beating until combined.
  5. Add in mini chips and stir until incorporated.
  6. Line a baking sheet with parchment paper. Measure out approx 2 tsp of dough and place on baking sheet about 2 inches apart.
  7. Bake 7-8 minutes until puffed and just set.
  8. Let cookies cool approx 3 minutes on baking sheet, then place a peppermint patty in between 2 warm cookies and place on a wire rack to continue cooling. Gently press cookies together so as the chocolate melts, the cookies stick to the patty.


Leave a Reply

50 Comments on "Peppermint Patty Chocolate Cookie Sandwiches"

Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Colleen @ What

I can’t believe I haven’t thought to put York peppermint patties between cookies before. This is just brilliant. These are definitely a “betcha can’t eat just one” kind of cookie!


We are on the same baking page! I love it:)


I have done the extact same thing! I think it’s been about 3 times over the last few years, I wake up on the other side of the room because I jumped out of bed when I dreamt of a huge spider attacking me in bed. And it always takes me a few seconds to realize it was just a dream and I wonder how I got across the room. :/


Oh, I love these!!!

Averie @ Averie Cooks

Shelly they look delish! I made chocolate cookies and posted about them yesterday and really wanted to add peppermint but I didn’t. Next time 🙂 I love the sandwich filling layer of peppermint pattys you used! And the cookies themselves look perfect! Pinning!


simple yet sounds totally amazing!

Katrina @ Warm Vanilla Sugar

This is pretty much everything I want in a cookie. Love!


what a great idea! love these! might make them for a potluck at work!

Katrina @ In Katrina

Totally valid thought. And umm yeah rock star cookies.

Becca from It

spider ghosts are TOTALLY real… don’t let anyone else tell you otherwise. However, I heard that keeping a stash of these cookies next to you is a spider ghost deterrent. So, please make some more. quickly.

Amber | Bluebonnets & Brownies

Please tell me you are bringing these to my cookie swap. PLEASE? Holy chocolate and mint brilliance, batman.

Anne Weber-Falk

I’m not a fan of mixing cookies with candy but I will totally do this. These look great. I know my family will be all over these too.

Elizabeth@ Food Ramblings

amazing! love these!

Jessica Gonzalez

Holy Moly!!! I am soooo making these for my Cookie Swap Party!! Question – is it two tsp. of baking soda or is that second baking soda suppose to be baking powder?? Thanks in advance!!


My oldest would love these! She really likes peppermint patties. I also wake my husband up to look for spiders!

Erin @ Dinners, Dishes and Desserts

Loved your other version of these, and I love this one for the holidays! Anything with chocolate and mint is a good thing.


Looks so delicious! I could so eat some right now!


oh I hope you saw what I did with the peppermint patty’s?
so good.
see peppermint is my favorite to bake with. While everyone loves pumpkin, I’m happy to be in the peppermint season now.
your dreams sound like your body is trying to get rid of a lot of built up stress.
that’s what i was told when i had a bout of them.
wasn’t this a great comment? lol

Hayley @ The Domestic Rebel

Simply genius. And ugh, when I’m stressed, I have really vivid dreams about zombies chasing me. It’s AWFUL.

Liz @ Tip Top Shape

Oh, these look delightful!

Mercedes@Satisfy My Sweet Tooth

These look so fabulous I cannot wait to make them! I love all other kinds of candy incorporated into cookies, so why not Peppermint Patties?! Great idea!


Those dreams are the WORST! Hopefully youve used up your quota for this year. Or…not if it means we keep getting peppermint chocolate heaven recipes like this out of ’em!

Nikki @Pennies on a Platter

I have to make these for my Dad, stat! He’s the resident peppermint patty lover in our fam… and his birthday is coming up. Perfect! 🙂

Lisa | With Style and Grace

oh yes, this is my kind of cookie!


This is awesome!! I would totally gobble all of these cookies!

Sarah B.

Looking at these is making my mouth water! 🙂


yes to everything. i do the same thing to my hubby with my crazy dreams. AND peppermint patties are my favorite, so i need about 6 dozen of these.

also. hot chocolate made with that special dark cocoa? insane.

Jen @ Jen

It seems there is nothing like the threat of death by arachnid to spark the creative genius in you. This cookie is definitely a flash of brilliance! Love it!

sue @ cakeballs, cookies and more

I hate that, dreams that are so scary but really dumb, LOL. But the cookies, those are awesome!

Live a Sweet Life

These are seriously making me very, very hungry.

Erin @ Making Memories

Ha! Seems like a valid conclusion. No one wants to be murdered by spider or man =o) And your cookies look wonderful!!!

Luv What You Do

What an awesome idea to use the patty as a filling. These look incredible!


Shelly, This is GENIUS!

Rachel @ Baked by Rachel

I HATE dreams like that. Nightmares of any kind are the absolute worst. Maybe you should keep a stash of these next to your bed to munch on when you can’t get back to sleep.

Kelli @ The Corner Kitchen

I’m a sucker for anything with Peppermint Patties! These cookies look like bites of heaven!

Loretta | A Finn In The Kitchen

That cut cookie shot totally looks like a way better version of an oatmeal cream pie!

Kiersten @ Oh My Veggies

I have dreams like that too! They are awful. I’m sure when we lived in an apartment, our neighbors hated me. I think I might make these for Christmas this year–you had me at easy.

Darla | Bakingdom

Such a simple, brilliant idea!!


These looks amazing!! Love your blog!


Would these freeze? I am trying to bake ahead for Christmas.

Christina @ Oven Adventures

i really have no words to describe your genius.


My Greg would love these!
Genius baking the peppermint patty right into the cookie!

Angie Big Bears Wife

Sorry that you had a creepy spider murder man dream but I’m also, glad that you did because without that dream you wouldn’t have these cookies haha. I can already see that you’re going to be a favorite on chocolate and peppermint patties what’s not to love……. Well I mean except for the creepy spider dream I don’t want to have anything to do with that haha

Angie Big Bears Wife

Add comment should have said “I can tell that these are going to be a favorite”….

Michael Koons

So you are suppose to use the fun size miniature York Peppermint Patties for these cookies correct?


I wonder if another type of cookie flavor would work? The idea sounds delicious!!