Cookies & Cups > Recipes > Dessert > No Bake Desserts > Gingerbread Pop Tart Ice Cream Sandwiches

Gingerbread Pop Tart Ice Cream Sandwiches

This is an easy recipe for homemade Ice Cream Sandwiches, made with vanilla bean ice cream and festive Gingerbread Pop Tarts! These ice cream treats are such a fun holiday dessert to make with kids!

An assortment of Pop Tart ice cream sandwiches in front of a box of Gingerbread Pop Tarts.

Food shopping isn’t my favorite thing.

I know some people love it and say it’s therapeutic and relaxing and yada yada.

Not me.

I am not a good food shopper.

This is probably the case because I am not a good planner.

I know lists work.

I know coupons work.

And I really have no excuse about dinner ideas.

The thing is, I am a great NON-food shopper…really unyielding when it comes to shoes, clothes or make-up.

Food just takes the joy out of shopping.  Maybe because I HAVE to do it, or that people are depending on me to stock the pantry with food for dinner.  It’s just when something becomes an obligation it crosses over into “fun sponge” territory.

But ever since Target added the “produce section” I have fallen a bit out of love. It’s really sad, like saying that you and your best friend have grown apart.

And you know what I REALLY hate?  The self check out lanes at the supermarket. No! No! NO!

I mean, now shopping is not only a hassle but I have to check myself OUT?

Don’t get me wrong, I am all for avoiding human contact and awkward chatter with the checker-outer, but that self scanner…I have to do volunteer work too?

I haven’t been trained in produce names.

What if I forgot my “bonus card”?

Put too many items on the belt the lights starts flashing and the sleepy “self check-out” monitor has to come cancel and rescan your stuff.  BECAUSE I’M NOT SMART ENOUGH TO WORK AT A SUPERMARKET!  But guess what?  Sleepy “self check-out” monitor is NEVER around because she is helping all the other scanning challenged people.

While I wait (my lane light flashing) I watch all the other people who took the lazy way out come and go with their baskets full of “sacked for you” bags.  It makes me jealous and full of resentment.

Plus, I’m not really that up on current events, but don’t people NEED jobs?  I mean giving perfectly good checker-outer jobs away to futurey self check-out lanes just seems unpatriotic.

So yeah.

I don’t enjoy the supermarket. That’s why I try and send my husband.

The only downside to that is, he comes home with copious amounts of junk food.  Ring Dings, Squeeze Cheese, Pop Tarts…

He’s my beast of burden.  I love you, honey.

Needless to say, there is rarely a shortage of Pop Tarts in our house.  But I am a lemons into lemonade kinda gal.   Not that Pop Tarts are lemons…it’s just when you have 6 boxes currently in your pantry you need to get creative.

I saw this idea in the fabulously adorable book CakeSpy Presents Sweet Treats for a Sugar Filled Life.  You need this book.  I met Jessie on a trip last June to Wilton and I will tell you that she is as cute and sweet as the treats in her book.  Again, go buy it now.

Since it’s the holiday season,  I decided to give the fun Pop Tart ice cream sandwich idea a wintery twist with Gingerbread Pop Tarts.  Aren’t they awesome?

A box of Gingerbread Pop Tarts.

I let the ice cream sit out for a few minutes to soften.  It will spread much easier.

A tub of Haagen-Dazs vanilla bean ice cream next to Gingerbread Pop Tarts.

I spread some softened ice cream on top of a Pop Tart, leaving a little space at the edges, so the ice cream doesn’t squeeze out.

Ice cream is spread over one side of a Gingerbread Pop Tart.

I used vanilla bean ice cream so the gingerbread flavor could be the star of the show.

An open-faced Pop Tart ice cream sandwich waiting for its other half.

Then I gently placed another Pop Tart on top.

A Gingerbread Pop Tart Ice Cream Sandwich on a plate.

I wrapped the ice cream sandwich up in cling wrap and placed it in the freezer, so the ice cream could re-freeze.

An ice cream sandwich wrapped in plastic wrap.

I cut them in half to serve…

Gingerbread Pop Tart ice cream sandwiches stacked in a row on a plate, next to an ice cream scoop.

Aren’t they pretty?

I am dying over the flavor combinations we could come up with!

S’mores Pop Tarts with chocolate ice cream. Cookies and Cream Pop Tarts with Cookies and Cream ice cream.  Strawberry Pop Tarts with coconut ice cream…Brown Sugar Cinnamon Pop Tarts with Butter Pecan ice cream..sigh…

Rate this recipe and share a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

I accept the Privacy Policy

27 comments on “Gingerbread Pop Tart Ice Cream Sandwiches”

  1. Sweet kitty! I’m so glad I’m not the only one who is despised by the self check-out machines at the grocery. I can use them if forced to but it usually ends badly for one of us.

  2. Erika - The Teenage Taste

    Oh my gosh, these look deeeeelicious! Glad I’m not the only one that’s still obsessed with ice cream when its 30 degrees outside! 🙂

  3. Cookie Sleuth

    Very creative use of Pop Tarts! I like grocery shopping, but only if the store isn’t busy…

  4. Wow!! I am SO not a pop tart person, but these look amazing enough I may have to try them!!!! Love this post 🙂

Scroll to Top