Oreo Cookie Filling Dip

This is basically a Oreo Filling Recipe… BUT I’m using it as a dip for all sorts of fun things!

While some recipes are completely unnecessary for your health, they are completely necessary for your life.

This is totally that.


With Oreos being made bigger and better all the time.. I mean, hello Mega Stuf…my husband and I are wondering when they were just gonna do away with the cookie altogether?


I mean, it’s all about the filling.  Does anyone even BUY regular Oreos anymore?  The motto in our house has always been if it isn’t a Double Stuf, then it’s a Diet Oreo.

And now with the Mega rocking our world…


I left my husband and my  7 year old home with a pack of Oreos in the cabinet and this is what they do…


So we are clearly a filling household.

Until the folks over at Nabisco get their act together and sell the filling alone, I decided to take matters into my own hands.


With Oreo Cookie Filling Dip.

I think I have come remarkably close to the filling, except I made it a slightly smoother consistency, so it’s a little easier to spread…dip…spoon…inhale…

Oreo Cookie Filling Dip | Cookies and Cups

ORRRR you can fill your own cookies…

Oreo Cookie Filling Dip | Cookies and Cups

It really couldn’t be easier to make..and yes, I know that vegetable shortening isn’t health food.

But this is OREO FILLING DIP.  If you’re looking for healthy today, you’ve come to the wrong spot.

Just mix together some shortening, powdered sugar, water and vanilla…


And that’s it. Dump it all in your bowl and mix it up!

Oreo Cookie Filling Dip | Cookies and Cups




Oreo Cookie Filling Dip


  • 1/4 cup vegetable shortening
  • 1/4 cup butter, room temperature
  • 1/2 tsp vanilla
  • 1 tsp granulated sugar
  • 3 1/2 cups powdered sugar
  • 3 Tbsp hot water


  1. Mix all ingredients with mixer for 2 minutes.
  2. Store in an airtight container for up to a week.




113 Responses

  1. Larissa

    Genius! My husband and kids will love this! Great for our next party…I usually put out a chocolate fountain, but next time it’s oreo filling dip, for sure. Yuuuuummmmmm.

  2. MelindaB

    The only thing that I would buy regular Oreos for is to make Oreo crust for pie or cheesecake. Or Oreo truffles. I swear that Nabisco briefly sold tubs of just Oreo filling over a decade ago, but that could completely be a dream that I had that I got confused with reality. Now I can make this, and my son and daughter will be over the moon. (Literally, from the sugar rush.)

    1. Jo-Anne

      I once saw just the Oreo Cookie in a large tub at Ocean State Job Lot. I wondered why anyone would just buy the chocolate cookie!

  3. I must be the only person who buys the regular ones…and wishes they sold a reduced filling version. By way of explanation: I’m a dunker, and that filling feels weird after the cookie’s all soggy. But YOUR filling…I might have to make some cookies to go with it πŸ™‚

  4. I am all for more filling πŸ™‚ Do the mega Oreos have 3x the filling or something like that?? I haven’t ever seen them in the store, but I will be looking for them now. πŸ™‚ Great recipe, pinning it.

    1. I THINK the mega oreos are like like a double stuff and a regular oreo put together. At least, in the one package that i have eaten, that’s the way the cream looks to me.

        1. shelly

          omg, I watched the video…that guy! He made sacrifices for .04 years making the machine πŸ™‚ Makes me laugh and cry all at once!

  5. Yes! I have been wondering why they even make the regular Oreo’s anymore. I thought the Mega Stuff was just too much though. I do love your idea for making your own filling for dipping things into.

  6. I, on occasion, have been known to just peel the filling out of the cookies and eat that while just tossing the cookies. not proud of it, but it happens. this dip.is.my.kryptonite. I just know it.

  7. I made this last night because I have no self control or restraint and figured that a cold Tuesday night was enough of an occasion for such a treat. Umm, YOU’RE MY HERO. My family was A-Mazed by this. And I’m ashamed to admit I didn’t really think to buy anything to dunk it in so sure enough we ate it…with a spoon. Not my finest moment. So good and simple and had everything on hand, well, except for dipping vessels but those are overrated anyway.

      1. I did pick up some dipping vessels last night, mini Oreos which really are basically tiny cookie chips with no filling, so it provided the freedom to completely load it up with this dip. It was fabulous but I still almost prefer the spoon method. :)Also, I shared some at work today and basically my picture was put up on the wall immediately naming me Employee of the Year. πŸ™‚ This just may be my favorite recipe of yours EVER and I have made and loved ALOT of them.

  8. I can’t stand it. I mean that in the best possible way. This may be as addicting as that peanut butter spread you made back in January. Holy cow.

  9. Joan

    If you are using the Oreo cookie for chocolate cookie crumbs, you really want the regular Oreos. Otherwise you have way too much filling. And I know someone who would be willing to take that extra filling off your hands.


  10. Too funny!!! I just HAD to share this recipe on my blog today.

    The Oreo filling dip reminds of a story about a guy I used to date. Isn’t it strange how a simple thing like Oreos can be such a topic and memory jogger?

    What does Double Stuffed Oreos vs. Original Oreos have to do with dating? Go to my blog and find out.

      1. I had forgotten about him saying it was a ‘deal breaker’ until I read your post. Again, I didn’t care… I compromised by taking his regular oreos and doubling up the cream filling myself πŸ™‚ For Christmas one year he actually purchased me a cake pan to bake cakes to look like an oreo cookie. I guess I should have taken his comment seriously THEN… but I didn’t. I fell head over heels in love with him… and then he dumped me. Ugh! I still have the cake pans. I plan on baking a yummy chocolate cake and fill it with your yummy recipe.

        Keep up the great recipes! I don’t make most of them… but love to read about them.

  11. You just got me in DEEP trouble. The filling is my favorite part and I’ll actually take out the filling and save it for last after I make my way through the cookies (Oh, what a hard thing that is to do…)! Now, I can just bypass the cookies all together!

  12. Shelley

    Can you even believe that my honey PREFERS regular Oreos, and says the double stuff is just “too much stuff.” Yep, I know, he’s insane.

  13. The best part of the oreo is the middle! I love this recipe–it is great you figured out how to make it yourself and eliminate whatever junk they probably put it in!

    1. Shelly

      The only thing I could guess is you added a bit too much vanilla and water or not enough powdered sugar? You could add a bit more powdered sugar to help with the consistency.

  14. Vickie

    I just found your site this morning and have already made these. Really good. The only thing I did differently is that I used milk instead of water. I thought they would have a creamier taste that way. Just remember that if you use milk instead of water it will need to be refrigerated. Another thing, this recipe seems very versatile. Next time I’m going to use lemon instead of vanilla and put it between sugar cookies. You could also use mint w/ either brownies or chocolate wafer cookies.
    To James above, diabetes is caused by a poorly functioning pancreas and controlled by diet and exercise. There is no food that causes diabetes. Thank you for all your concern about our kids though.

  15. Leslie

    I am going to make these today for my family reunion. I love Oreo’s but am not a fan of all the crazy flavors they are coming out with. Candy Corn and Carmel Apple Oreos, just doesn’t seem right.

  16. Lisa

    Ha! There is an ad for prescription cholesterol treatment right in the middle of the recipe today. Coffee came out my nose. I, too, love the pic of your kiddo with his standard size Oreo. πŸ˜‰ Thanks so much for the recipe. When the test recipe gives you bland chocolate cookie dough….make Oreos.

  17. Pingback : Oreo Cookie Bark – Fortune New

  18. Pingback : Oreo Cookie Bark – The Show Times

  19. Pingback : Oreo Cookie Bark – Note For Day

  20. Pingback : Oreo Cookie Bark – Longtimes

  21. Pingback : Oreo Cookie Bark – Furtune Life

  22. Pingback : Oreo Cookie Bark

  23. Pingback : Oreo Cookie Bark - TrendXnow

  24. Pingback : Oreo Cookie Bark | Tutorials4all

  25. Pingback : Oreo Cookie Bark - recipequicks

  26. Pingback : Oreo Cookie Bark - Cravings Happen

  27. Pingback : Oreo Cookie Bark – Chow Hub

  28. Pingback : OREO COOKIE BARK - assortedcookieco

  29. Pingback : Oreo Cookie Bark – TrendXnow

  30. Pingback : Oreo Cookie Bark – PatchWork Cooking

  31. Linda

    I tried this and it tasted a lot like chemical filled store bought frosting. I’ve tried adding a lot of salt, more butter, more sugar, etc and nothing seems to fix it…

  32. Pingback : 6 Donut Dessert Mashups to Satisfy All Your Sweet Cravings – RR-Magazine

  33. Pingback : 6 Donut Dessert Mashups to Satisfy All Your Sweet Cravings - Okay Optimism

  34. Stephanie

    Do you think I could use this to frost a cake? My son’s favorite thing in the world is Oreo filling and I was thinking of making a cake and using this for frosting.

Leave a Reply