Banana Pie Cookies

Soft Banana Pie Cookies...a thick, banana pudding cookie topped with creamy vanilla frosting!

These Banana Pie Cookies are so soft and delicious…they’re loaded with banana pudding mix and topped with a creamy vanilla frosting!

I feel like you’re either a banana lover or you’re not. No gray area on this one.

I fondly avoid banana as a fruit.


Wait…but in a baked good, I’m all in.

But NOT banana flavored candy. Ack.

But totally in a smoothie.

Dude. Gray area for days.

I have no idea what I am saying.

Anyhow, today we’re taking banana flavored pudding and throwing it in a cookie. So a negative and a positive makes a positive in my math.


Who knew bananas were so confusing?


Anyhow Imperial Sugar asked me to whip up some Banana Pie Cookies.

And I did. Check them out…

Banana Pie Cookies

Hop over to Imperial Sugar today for the FULL RECIPE!

Leave a Reply

15 Comments on "Banana Pie Cookies"

Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Nikki @Seeded at the Table

Wow! Amazing cookies! I hear you on the banana candy…bleck!! But, all other forms of banana, I’m in. No gray area for me. šŸ˜‰

Laura @ Lauras Baking Talent

I’ve made cookies with banana pudding before and they were delicious… so I’m sure these taste fantastic… but then again I love banana everything šŸ™‚

Sammi @Sammi Sunshine

I love your perspective on bananas. And the cookies. šŸ™‚


These sound delicious! I love banana in most everything!

Averie @ Averie Cooks

but in a baked good, Iā€™m all in. <— SAME. Not into it by itself but in (vegan) baking especially or in smoothies, cannot go without! Love this idea! pinned

Jennifer N.

It’s nice to know there is another person that has the same wonky aversion to bananas that I do! šŸ˜€

Lindsay Ann @ Lindsay Ann Bakes

You got me!!! That cookie center looks so moist and full of deliscious goodness! Oooh and cookies with frosting on top… perfection!

Heather @ My Overflowing Cup

These look delicious. Pudding mix adds such a soft texture to cookies. Thanks for the recipe!

Jess @ Sweet Menu

Ooh these cookies look amazing! So with you on banana flavoured candy – yuck! But banana muffins and breads – yumo!

Emily @ Life on Food

I love bananas in all forms, except candy. I am with you on that one.

Chloe @ foodlikecake

These cookies are adorable!

Cookbook Queen

No banana Laffy Taffy? You have lost your dang mind. But I love these gorgeous cookies šŸ™‚

Samina | The Cupcake Confession

Yes to everything banana flavored! These cookies are insanelyyyy delicious!

Kelley J

I made these for a cookie competition at work – and won! šŸ™‚
The coworkers are always requesting them now, I make these like once a week. lol I also made them for my mom for mother’s day!
Only thing I change is a little less sugar in the frosting to keep it from being overly sweet.