Brownie Bottom Ice Cream Cake

Brownie Bottom Ice Cream Cake is the best ice cream cake made with fudgy brownies, chocolate frosting, and cookie dough ice cream!

This Brownie Bottom Ice Cream Cake is the BEST Ice Cream Cake EVER! You’ve got a thick fudgy brownie layer on the bottom topped with creamy chocolate frosting, cookie dough ice cream, whipped cream and sprinkles!

My kids are fairly jaded when it comes to desserts. When they come home from school and there is a giant plate of cookies waiting for them, they don’t even waggle an eyebrow. Same old, same old. They have even, on occasion, bypassed my fresh baked cookies for Oreos. I kid you not.

BUT since I just chalk that up to kids being weird, I don’t let them get to me. However, they do, every so often, have a pretty fab idea. Which bring me to…

The BEST Ice Cream Cake In All of the Land!

Brownie Bottom Ice Cream Cake can be made with your favorite ice cream flavor!

I cannot take full credit for the inception of this cake. You wanna know why? I actually don’t like ice cream cake. GASP I KNOW.

Let me explain a quick minute before I lose you. The thing is generally ice cream cakes are…well…all ice cream. I know, I know, duh. I am an oddball. Ice cream isn’t my favorite. I mean I love it when ice cream is filled with delicious extras, but I kinda-sorta pick those out and leave all the ice cream.

But that’s why this is the BEST Ice Cream Cake…it is filled with all sorts of other yummy things that while it is definitely an ice cream cake, it is a Brownie Bottom Ice Cream Cake topped with chocolate frosting, cookie dough ice cream, whipped cream and sprinkles. You’re into this, right?

How To Make Ice Cream Cake

How To Make Brownie Bottom Ice Cream Cake

It’s really super simple, and there are tons of variations that we will get to in a minute. But first let’s start with the basics:

  1. Bake up some brownies in an 8×8 or 11×7 pan.  But make sure the pan has deep sides, because you are going to be topping the brownie with all the extras and you don’t want it to overflow! I used a boxed brownie mix for ease in this recipe, but 100% absolutely you can bake brownies from scratch. My Fudgy Brownies recipe would work great! More on the size of the brownie mix in a minute.
  2. Top the brownies with some frosting! You can make your own homemade chocolate frosting, or certainly you can use canned chocolate frosting. Completely up to you and your willingness. Pop the pan in the fridge for 30 minutes to let the frosting set up.
  3. While the frosting is chilling, pull out your ice cream from the freezer to let it soften up, so it will spread easily.
  4. You’re pretty much done at this point. Cover the cake with cling wrap and let it freeze for a few hours.
  5. When you’re ready to serve it up, make some homemade whipped cream and spread that on top of the ice cream and then finally SPRINKLES!

The BEST Ice Cream Cake ever is Brownie Bottom Ice Cream Cake!

This Ice Cream Cake is TOTALLY Adaptable!

Here’s where I am going to try to answer all your questions! There are TONS of adaptations to this “recipe”, and I wan tto set you up for success. So let’s chat…

What Size Brownie Mix Do I Use?

Ok, here’s the deal. I wrote this recipe using a “regular” sized brownie mix, not a “Family Size” brownie mix. Generally a “Family Size” brownie mix says Bake in a 9×13 Pan on the front. When I buy and make Family Size brownies I always bake them in a 9×9 pan, because I like thicker brownies. But for this recipe a thicker brownie in a 9×9 pan might not leave enough room for all your ice cream unless the pan has tall sides. AND if you use a 9×13 sized pan, the layers of brownie, ice cream, and frosting will be super thin. Have I confused you yet?

So the recipe is written for a 10-ish ounce brownie mix, not an 18-ish ounce brownie mix. BUT. Here’s where I am really going to mess with your brain. You can EASILY make this recipe in a 9×13 pan, you will just need to increase the amount of frosting, ice cream and whipped cream by about a third.

Trust me, you’re not going to mess ANYTHING up. Make it as big or as small as you want, it’s totally up to you. Use this recipe as a guideline and get creative!

Side note – I have even made this using a Family Sized Brownie mix in a 9×9 pan with all the rest of the measurements the same, it just almost overflowed my pan because I didn’t decrease the amount of ice cream, but I wan’t made about it! 

Can I Use Different Flavors of Ice Cream?

1000% yes! Cookie Dough is my favorite, so that’s what I used. But imagine the flavor possibilities:

  • Mint Chocolate Chip Ice Cream: This would be so amazing on top of the brownie and chocolate frosting. You could even use mini chocolate chips instead of sprinkles!
  • Strawberry Ice Cream: You would have a Neapolitan situation going on!
  • Vanilla: Nothing wrong with a little plain vanilla for the purest!
  • Rocky Road: This could be great with chopped peanuts on top of the whipped cream!
  • Cookies and Cream: Imagine this with chopped Oreo cookies as a garnish!
  • Butter Pecan: Top the brownie with caramel instead of frosting and sprinkle the whipped cream with chopped candied pecans!

Will the Brownie Be Frozen and Solid?

Nope! Here are my tips to brownie success when it comes to this ice cream cake:

  • Under-bake the brownie a bit. This is normal for me, as I prefer ooey-gooey brownies, but if you’re a rule follower and like to bake a brownie all the way, consider bending the rules slightly here.
  • I bake brownies until a toothpick inserted an inch or two from the edge of the pan comes out clean. If the toothpick inserted in the center comes out clean, it’s over-baked in my book.
  • An under-baked brownie in this recipe will stay softer.
  • Also make sure you allow the cake to sit out for 15-20 minutes or so before you slice it! Of course it will be rock solid if you try and eat it straight from the freezer…I mean, it’s frozen! So let it warm up a touch and you’ll be set!

Brownie Bottom Ice Cream Cake is the best party cake!

Looking for More Ice Cream Recipes? Try These:

This recipe was originally posted in 2013, but the recipe, tips and pictures have been updated!

Print
Brownie Bottom Ice Cream Cake is the best ice cream cake made with fudgy brownies, chocolate frosting, and cookie dough ice cream!

Brownie Bottom Ice Cream Cake

  • Prep Time: 10 minutes
  • Cook Time: 20 minutes
  • Total Time: 30 minutes
  • Yield: serves 10 1x
  • Category: Cake
  • Method: Oven
  • Cuisine: Dessert

Description

This Ice Cream Cake is the perfect party cake!


Ingredients

  • 1 (10-15 ounces) Brownie Mix, made according to package directions in an 8×8 pan
  • 1 1/2 cups chocolate frosting
  • 1.5 quarts Cookie Dough Ice Cream
  • 1 cup heavy whipping cream
  • 1/4 cup granulated sugar
  • sprinkles to garnish

Instructions

  1. Line an 8×8 or 11×7 deep-dish baking dish with foil and coat with nonstick spray. Sides of the pan need to come up at least 3 inches to leave room for the ice cream and whipped cream layer.
  2. Bake the brownies according to package directions in the prepared pan and allow to cool completely.
  3. Spread chocolate frosting onto cooled brownies.
  4. Place frosted brownies in refrigerator.
  5. Remove ice cream from freezer and allow to soften for about 30 minutes while the brownies are chilling.
  6. Remove the brownies from the refrigerator and top with ice cream, spreading evenly with an off-set spatula.
  7. Cover and place in freezer for at least 3 hours.
  8. Before serving prepare your whipped cream. Place heavy whipping cream in bowl of stand mixer fitted with the whisk attachment and add in granulated sugar. Beat cream on high speed for about 2 minutes until it becomes thick.
  9. Spread onto ice cream cake, top with sprinkles and serve immediately.

Notes

Store air-tight in freezer for up to 2 weeks. Allow to soften 15 minutes before serving.

Keywords: cookies and cups, ice cream cake, brownies, cake recipe, ice cream, whipped cream, sprinkles

Brownie Bottom Ice Cream Cake

 

106 Responses

  1. You know who says hooray? I do. Not even kidding. (you knew we were friends for a reason — you need a hooray person in your life)

    I am so excited about this brownie cake — Jon David will LOVE IT!!!

  2. Shelllllly- you are the best! I love putting the idea of putting the frosting in the cake. This looks phenomenal. I’m so excited to make this! I think I may layer with the chocolate frosting. Hm.

  3. I’m seriously enjoying the store-bought aspects of this epic treat. I mean, I went to baking school this year, and sometimes I’m all: seriously? I need something NOW. Screw you, Scratch! (And then I eat a bag of chips.) I’m pretty sure I need to make this cake immediately.

      1. Krystal

        I mad this for my family and they liked it but couldn’t eat the brownie it was to hard. I had an aweful time cutting through it. Any tips?? I didn’t burn the brownies I even pulled them out a little early so they were soft. But now of that matters when you freeze it. Wonder how an Oreo crust would work.

        1. Shelly

          That’s strange. I have made it twice and while the brownie does firm up in the freezer, it can be cut through and eaten without an issue. I am sure an oreo crust would work great too, though!

        2. Sarah

          I haven’t made it myself yet, but is it possible that because you took the brownie out early, it was “soft” but also dense? Then when frozen it makes it even harder to cut through? I would think if the brownie were more “cake-like” it would be easier to eat when frozen.

  4. Holly

    Oh this looks ridiculous and I mean that in the best possible way. Do you think using Brownie Batter ice cream would be overkill? Yeah I didn’t think so. šŸ™‚

  5. My niece was very excited about something yesterday and I joined in by saying “Hooray!” She looked at me all serious and said “Stop it.” So, I guess “hooray” is definitely out. Tell your family.

    Love this! Want this. Must make this.

  6. Is there a chance to get adopted by you?
    I’d waggle my eyebrows to death and give you nicknames like ‘world’s best gooey melting cookie ice crem MUMMY’ every day!

  7. Angie Bennett

    My son told me he wanted a cake with sugar cookies, ice cream, chocolate sauce and whipped cream. Trying to figure that one out….

  8. Cindy

    Ok, when is the next holiday or pot luck??? I’m on a diet (and shouldn’t have even READ this recipe but…… Let’s see…..Payday Friday! That’s a holiday in my book! Let’s celebrate!!!!

  9. My 15 year old requested an ice cream cake for his birthday. Not one I made either. I was a little insulted but then i realized it’s because we ALWAYS have cake or cookies or something working in the kitchen so it’s just something he’s not used to getting very often. At least that’s how I’m going to interpret it.

    This does look good. I like the chocolate frosting in the middle. I think brownies always need frosting.

  10. Ok so my birthday is in 10 days…
    I NEED this!!! And I have a feeling I will be making it for myself. Or at least making it for my fiance’s birthday. And mint-chip ice cream would be AMAZING, you’re right! Though, cookie dough is fab, so I don’t know how I’ll choose!

  11. Ashley Dicey

    This looks absolutely delicious! I was wondering if you can use store bought whipped cream? I don’t not have a stand alone mixer:(

  12. Heather

    Your son is a genius for requesting and your are genius for creating this. Thanks for sharing! *hurries of to buy ice cream and brownies*

  13. Georgia

    This looks so delicious! I can’t wait to try it. One question, instead of making the whipped cream, would it work if I used Cool Whip instead?

  14. Jana Allen

    This looks amazing!! Why two weeks for freezing though? Do you have to freeze it for that long or could you eat it the same day you make it. I’m impatient! lol!

  15. I tried making this once! Except on a much smaller scale since the birthday girl already had another cake.

    This looks delicious!! I love how you added the frosting in the middle!

  16. breanna

    You know why you like it so much? Because it’s not cake. It’s a brownie with ice cream, frosting, and whipped cream. You have made an ice cream brownie. Not an ice cream cake.

  17. Valerie

    Great recipe. I made this for my husbands birthday and he loved it. Rather than chocolate frosting I used a thin layer of hot fudge topping and ground up chocolate chips (used a mini food processor). I put that on right after the brownie layer. Since the cake was just for two I used an 8×8 pan and used half of a family size brownie mix. I cut the brownie ingredients in half (one egg instead of two, half the oil). Came out very good- like a thick crust instead of a brownie portion. I might use cool whip instead of making whipped cream next time just to make it a little faster.

  18. Carter Hudson

    I tried birthday cake ice cream and it tased so good! My family said it was beautiful. It was actually possible! I just took some of that edible spray and the BOOM! It was a dream come true!

  19. Wow, the ice cream cake look SO GOOD. I’m sure the taste as well. I love Ice cream & I love brownies. Never tough to combine both. So Cool! I will try it someday with my home made vanilla ice cream.Great Recipe šŸ™‚ Thanks.

  20. Anna

    Sounds fab! How long before the ice cream starts melting and getting yucky/messy? Just wondering how long of a drive it could sit through if I made it and brought it somewhere…? I can usually travel with a DQ cake from store to home and that’s about a 20min. drive.

  21. Leslie

    What square pan did you use? I used our 8×8 pyrex for the brownies and the bottom 2 layers are sitting in the fridge right now and I have maybe an inch for ice cream :/ and I know I got the normal brownies, not family sized. So I just think my dish wasn’t deep enough! Looks like it will HAVE to overflow šŸ™‚

    1. Shelly

      I used my 8×8 pan… very strange that it would overflow.. maybe my pan has higher sides than yours? You could certainly make it in a 9×9 pan and just have a thinner brownie layer. Just adjust bake time for the brownie!

  22. Carrie

    Ice cream cake is my favorite and I never knew it was actually this easy to make. :p I personally despise traditional frosting (I think it’s too sweet) and am the weirdo who will sit there and scrape most of it off the top of a cupcake before eating. Thanks for this! Gotta try it sometime.

  23. Jesia

    This looks amazing. Kind of like a DQ ice cream cake! Thanks for sharing. I can’t wait to make it. =)

    Also, would it be totally horrible to use Cool Whip instead of homemade whipped cream?

  24. I made this tonight, everything is great BUT my brownie turned out horrible from being frozen.. I did everything perfect!!! Kinda sucks.. is there any tips or specific brand u use!! And ill try again… thx so much

  25. Lindsey

    I am making this for my small group tonight and thankfully used an 11x 9 Pyrex. I haven’t even made it to the whipped cream step and my dish is filled to the brim! (I just purchased my Pyrex dish, so maybe the newer Pyrex dishes are more shallow?)

    I love how easy this recipe is…thank you, Shelly!

  26. Susan

    This cake is so delicious! I just made it for my husband’s birthday! I will make it again for sure! Thanks for sharing the recipe!

  27. Channa Ming

    Hi Shelly,

    I can’t wait to make this! So many awesome birthday memories involving ice cream cakes, but brownies are even better! Can you please tell me what pan you used? Brand name? Where you got it? It looks nice and deep and I would love to find one like that. Is it 3 inches high? Any info/help would be much appreciated. Thank you!

    Channa

  28. Marilyn

    Oh this looks delish – even better with Turkey Hill ice cream! We’re living overseas right now and can’t get our Turkey Hill fix, but we’ll be trying this for sure, TH or no TH! :-).

  29. It was my turn to bring birthday treats for a co-worker today at school. I made 2 of these in a 9 x 13 size. Let me tell you I was TOTALLY queen for the day (kinda stole the thunder from the birthday girl, LOL) They were BEAUTIFUL, and OH so delicious. I made the mistake of making them in the portable foil pans…the super tall lid on them was GREAT, but every slice I made cut through the metal pan. Oh, well. This is definitely going into my “DO AGAIN ASAP” recipe folder!

  30. Holly

    Looks amazing! I’m going to make for my sons Bday this weekend. Question… Can u make the whole thing and put it in the freezer? I’ll prob use cool whip instead and was wondering if it would mess it up if I put it on before we are ready to serve it? Thanks!!

  31. Laura

    I made this yesterday for a friend’s birthday and it was phenomenal! Boxed brownies, followed by some canned fudge icing, topped with a few crushed birthday cake Oreos, then cookies and cream ice cream, some crushed regular Oreos, then homemade whipped cream (with some added stabilizer so it would freeze well until being served today). I toolkit out 20 minutes before being served, and it was perfect.

    I love making decadent desserts from scratch, but it was so wonderful to take some shortcuts – and even better that it turned out to be one of the best desserts I’ve ever made!

    Thank you for such a great recipe.

  32. Mary

    wow I was on Pinterest and someone pinned your recipe..this is amazing and I can’t wait to make it for my family. We are not huge dessert eaters so when I make something this it’s a definite treat

    Thanks for sharing your talents and your recipe.

  33. Maria

    Hello Just wondering if you can freeze the whip cream as I want it made ahead of time not during the party. Looks Delicious!!!

  34. Amy

    Made this for a BBQ. I used hot fudge sauce instead of chocolate frosting. Chocolate chip ice cream. Used a 13×9 pan. More ice cream, whipped cream, etc.,. So good!

  35. I made this for my son’s girlfriend for her b-day. She loves anything brownie. But it turned out perfect! The best brownie desert I have ever had. I used cookie dough ice cream being as it’s her favorite flavor. I also used Betty crocker fudge brownies. Along with milk chocolate frosting and real whipped cream. I will make this again and again and again. We all absolutely loved it! Great recipe no matter what you want to call it.

  36. Michelle McElroy

    I made this today and it was really fantastic with our Memorial day cookout. I debated my pan choice a while… thinking my 8×8 wouldn’t leave enough height for ice cream and whipped cream, I split my brownie batter between 2 loaf pans. It was perfect as far as accommodating all of the layers, but the brownie layer was too thick and super rich. Next time ( oh yes, there will definitely be a next time) I’ll use my spring form or a 13×9. Can’t wait to try Blondie bottom, strawberry jam, vanilla ice cream, whipped cream and then garnish with fresh strawberries. Thanks so much for the recipe. My family thinks I’m a master chef tonight!

  37. Austin

    Will be making this for my daughters birthday this weekend. I see that recipie stresses not to use family sized box of brownie mix. Need to double recipie for a larger crowd..use larger pan and double all ingredients? Thanks!

  38. Leslie

    Thank you for such a great recipe! I made it for a church function and It got rave reviews.
    Since it was “going to church” I did find a way to dress it up.
    I made it in a springform pan, lining bottom and sides with parchment paper. I left it in the pan and followed all directions until just before the whipped topping was added. At that point I released it from the pan and pulled off the parchment paper from the sides only. Then I covered the sides with cookie crumbs. I topped that with the whipped topping and some sprinkles.
    Thanks again.

  39. Pingback : Affogato - Bunny's Warm Oven

  40. Pingback : 26 Beautiful Brownie Bottom Recipes | Chief Health

  41. Pingback : 18 Delicious Brownie Bottom Desserts - Style Motivation

  42. Jody

    Made this as a birthday cake. Had a hard time getting the brownies off the bottom of the pan. Where on Earth do you find an 8×8 pan with 3 inch sides? Very good

  43. Shantel

    HeLP!! Lol I assembled my cake but I did a brownie layer then ice cream and then brownie again and then I put cool whip over the whole thing.. will it be ok over night? The cake is for tomorrow night..Iā€™m scared the brownie will be rock hard ??

    1. Shelly

      The frozen brownie will get a bit hard, so I definitely recommend letting it sit out for a bit to soften up before serving. Obviously not too long, so the ine cream melts, but I’d give it at least 15 minutes or so!

  44. Kids loved it. very good and easy recipe, i tried it with strawberry flavor ice cream and added some dry fruits . it was woo..very yummy. thanks for sharing.

Leave a Reply