Peeps Cake Batter Candy

Um yeah, Peeps.  I am a fan.


And lately I have noticed Peeps popping up at other times of the year…Halloween, Christmas, Valentines…I love it!

And now:  Party Cake Peeps.

Indeed, this IS real life.

Basically, they’re Peeps that taste like Cake.  It’s all in honor of Peeps 60th anniversary.  Which is crazy!  I mean, can you imagine people in the ’50s eating Peeps?


Anyhow this flavor might possibly be the best invention of the year.

Party Cake Peeps are currently a Walmart exclusive…and check out THIS SITE.  Walmart has this hilarious page, where you can vote in a new flavor of Peeps…and also customize it.  Like, you can give your Peep a face tattoo, or a fu manchu.  I swear.  It’s a crack up!

Anyhow, I am all about Peeps year-round.  They’re no longer just an Easter basket filler.  I mean, check out this fun site with tons of recipes and craft ideas using Peeps.

Honestly you can sub in Peeps in any recipe that calls for marshmallows.


When I got my sticky hands on a few boxes of the Party Cake Peeps I decided after I ate 10 of them, I should try them out in a new way.

So I made candy…that’s kinda like fudge, but totally isn’t fudge.


Peeps Cake Batter Candy.

Peeps Cake Batter Candy | Cookies and CupsThis recipe is kinda crazy…
First you need to perform a little Peeps surgery.
Cut them up into small pieces…
 photo IMG_8331_zpsc38e96bb.jpgThen you take a boxed cake mix and powdered sugar.  Whisk it together so there are no big lumps, and then add in some tabs of butter…
 photo PicMonkeyCollage-19_zps39a1e935.jpgPop that in the microwave with a little milk and then stir it all together. Let it cool for a few minutes.
It’ll be thick.

Then stir in your Peeps carnage and some white chocolate chips, if you want…
 photo PicMonkeyCollage2-4_zps210735f8.jpgIn a lined and sprayed pan press the whole mixture in.
Then you should top with a million sprinkles.
Press the sprinkles so they stick in the candy and then chill this mess for about 2 hours.
Then it will be ready to cut into pieces!
 photo PicMonkeyCollage3_zps58ee489f.jpgIsn’t it fun? It’s Party Cake overload!

Peeps Cake Batter Candy | Cookies and Cups

So yeah, Peeps all year round is totally a thing now.

I’ve even created a Pinterest board for my obsession.

And I tracked down some really fun ways to use Peeps all year round from some of my favorite sites:

S’mores Cookie Pops

Peeps Cupcakes

Peeps Sunflower Cake

Peeps Marshmallow Fondant

Peeps S’mores

Peeps Popcorn

Peeps Eclair Cake Cups



Peeps Cake Batter Candy


make 20 pieces of candy


  • 2 cups yellow cake mix
  • 2 cups powdered sugar
  • 1/2 cup butter, cut into tablespoon sized pieces
  • 1/4 cup milk
  • 15 Party Cake Peeps, cut into small pieces
  • *optional 1/2 cup white chocolate chips
  • 1/4 cup rainbow sprinkles


  1. Line an 8×8 pan with foil and spray with nonstick spray
  2. In a large bowl whisk together the cake mix and the powdered sugar, breaking up any large lumps.
  3. Add in tabs of butter and milk, don’t stir.
  4. Microwave for 2 minutes, remove and stir until it mixture comes together, it will be thick.
  5. Let it sit for a few minutes to cool slightly.
  6. Stir in white chocolate chips, if using, and Peeps.
  7. Press mixture evenly into prepared pan, and sprinkle the sprinkles on top, pressing into candy.
  8. Let chill in refrigerator for 2 hours before cutting into pieces.


store airtight for up to 3 days.
Can be stored at room temperature or in refrigerator

Recipe adapted from


*Disclosure:  I’ve partnered with Walmart and Peeps on this post for an exclusive endorsement of Party Cake Peeps. This blog post was sponsored, and while I was compensated, all opinions are honest and my own.  I only work with brands that I love and use outside of this blog.

25 Responses

  1. Oh boy! I could eat so much of that candy! I’m loving the cut up peeps that are hiding in it. Those cake flavored peeps were so awesome!!! Thanks for linking to my eclair cups 🙂

  2. I just HAVE to make this for my best friend. She adores peeps, and I know she’ll be over the moon when she sees these! Thank you so much for sharing. They look delicious!

  3. oh man this means i need a trip to walmart??! i have the vanilla ones that target has, but i think i need these blue speckled beauties! candy sounds amazing 🙂

  4. Pingback : 20 Peeps Recipes You Gotta Try This Easter | Mom Spark - Mom Blogger

Leave a Reply