S’mores Whoopie Pies

I don’t presume to think that everyone who comes to visit me here on my internet space actually READS what I write.

I am sure the majority of people don’t, actually.

A quick glance at the sugary treats and they are on to more important web-business like facebooking and pinteresting and twittering.

Yep, that was totally a shameless plug for all my social media hang-outs.  Sorry.



So anyway, I decided to do an experiment.

Because without coming across as too bratty, I can mostly tell when you leave comments here and you haven’t read what I wrote.

Which is cool.   I mean, I know you guys all have lives that go beyond me.  I cry a little at the thought, but I know it to be true.


But sometimes you guys make it so obvious.

While, I am NOT a secret agent who has Inspector Gadget-type spy stuff…I use pretty a simple process of elimination-style investigative tricks.

For example, I am certain you must not have read my post if you leave a comment asking me where I bought a particular item that I have linked to 40 times in said post.

Just a guess.

Another tactic of mine to catch the non-readers is when I  write stories that are really ridiculous.  I mean, remember that time I wrestled an electric eel, who bit me and made me glow?  So now I power my house with my finger.  It’s pretty awesome…a totally earth-friendly way to save electricity.

The reason I know you didn’t read that is because you don’t even mention it in your comment.  I get that the sugary treats are distracting, but seriously, I am now ELECTRIC.  That’s definitely comment-worthy.

Ok, fine.  I’m kidding, that didn’t happen.  I’m not electric.  Honestly I try not to go in the ocean at all.  It’s filled with crittery-critters who basically live life proving the idiom, “don’t poop where you eat”, wrong.  And since mixing poop with pleasure is against my religion, that explains my aversion to the ocean.


Don’t get me wrong I love your comments and wish more people would write them.

Alls I’m saying is that maybe if you’re going to take the time to write me a love note, make it a cool love note.  Don’t be scared to tell me what you’re thinking.  I mean, unless it’s really mean.  Because that wouldn’t be very nice.

True story, just yesterday I had someone leave me a comment telling me that I could graze their boob.  That really happened.  Read the comments on this post.  I’m not necessarily asking you to leave me suggestive commentary, but I felt the love on that one.


I really hope that didn’t come off as bratty.

Really you can do whatever… read, don’t read, whatever works for you, because honestly, I’m just glad you’re here 🙂


And to show you my love I am totally going to give you a sandwich cookie that will rock your world.

It’s a S’mores Whoopie Pie.

Which again, I SO didn’t invent.  This whole s’mores week has been a lesson in my mediocrity.  There are some smart people in the world and google tells me so on a daily basis.


S’mores Whoopie Pies.

Here’s what you do…

Crush some graham crackers up into a fine dust.

You’ll need a cup and a half, which is about 9 full crackers smushed.
Mix up your batter.
It will look like this…

Drop the batter by the tablespoon onto a lined baking sheet.

They will look like this when they are all baked up…

Next you have to make them happen. Flip half of them over…
Then melt up your milk chocolate bars and give one side of your sandwich a schmear.
Don’t neglect the other side. Cover him with some marshmallow buttercream.

That’s it! Squish those two lovebirds together and you’ll get this…
Isn’t she gorgeous?


S’mores Whoopie Pies


makes approx 20 whoopie pies


  • 1/2 cup butter, room temperature
  • 1 cup light brown sugar, packed
  • 1 1/4 cup flour
  • 1 1/2 cup finely crushed graham crackers (about 9 whole crackers)
  • 1 1/2 tsp baking powder
  • 2 eggs
  • 1/2 cup plus 2 Tbsp milk
  • 1 tsp baking soda
  • 1 tsp vinegar
  • 2 tsp vanilla
  • 6 (full sized, 1.55 oz) Hershey Bars
  • Marshmallow Buttercream


  1. Preheat oven to 375°
  2. Line baking sheets with parchment paper.
  3. Combine graham cracker crumbs, flour, and baking powder in bowl, set aside.
  4. In a small bowl stir milk, vanilla, baking soda and vinegar together, set this aside also.
  5. In mixer beat butter and brown sugar together for 2 minutes at medium speed.
  6. Add eggs and continue to beat until incorporated evenly.
  7. Turn speed to low and slowly add in flour mixture and milk mixture. Turn mixer up to medium and beat for an additional 1 minute.
  8. Drop by heaping tablespoon sized portions onto lined baking sheet. Place the batter at least 2 inches apart, as the cookies spread during baking.
  9. Bake 8-10 minutes until cookies are set.
  10. Let cool on baking sheet for 3 minutes and then transfer to wire rack to finish cooling.
  11. When all cookies are baked, melt chocolate bars in microwave on 50% power in 30 second increments, stirring after each 30 seconds. Continue until melted.
  12. Flip half of the cookies over and spoon a tablespoon sized portion of melted chocolate on the bottom, spreading to the edge of the cookie.
  13. Fill a piping bag or ziplock bag with prepared frosting and pipe frosting on the remaining, non-chocolate cookies. Leave room at the edge for the frosting to spread when sandwiched.
  14. Top your frosting side with the chocolate side.
  15. Store in an airtight container for up to 5 days, refrigerate if desired


adapted from Whoopie Pies


Leave a Reply

178 Comments on "S’mores Whoopie Pies"

Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted

I was feeling bratty back to the point where I was just going to post “ooh, these look delicious” or something else inane, but such an obvious troll could be just as easily mistaken for another skimmer. Which I am not!


Cassandra Holdeman

I love your blog! You have the best recipes and I am totally living through your S’Mores recipes this week as I am on a diet and not allowed anything ooey, gooey, and delicious like your recipes look. But you better believe that I pinned them, started following you on Pinterest (I already follow you by reader), and will be making at least one of the recipes next week when I can have sugar again. Also I think it is pretty cool how you can power your whole house with your finger. 🙂


I always read what you write! I don’t actually have much time for baking and experimenting and such, so most of the entertainment is reading your witty little musing. They’re almost always a hoot and a half.

Ash V

Kill me now with these! Eels kind of freak me out and have ever since I had a nightmare about them. Whenever I mention to people that I hate eels they think it’s because of The Princess Bride, but it’s not. It’s because of a dream (which, by the way, the odds of me actually remembering my dreams are about 1 in a million, cause I couldn’t tell you the last dream I remember).

Averie @ Averie Cooks

I love smores and I love that you made them, whoopie pie style. Those little whoopie cookies almost look like Nilla wafers. They look heavenly!

Emilie @ Emilie

I commented on yesterday’s post asking where you got the liners EVEN THOUGH I ALWAYS READ THE WHOLE THING!! and then i read today’s post, about how people ask you where you buy things when there are links, so I went back and looked at yesterday’s because i was SURE there was no way you linked to them and I missed it and……there it is. The link. Right before the recipe. Sigh. 🙂

Debby Pucci

I come here because of your recipes I will often leave a short comment. I didn’t think it was right to just open your post and pin it without saying something!

Living The Sweet Life

You’re electric – – COOL 😉 lol. I never thought about the under water swimming where the fishy’s poop – – that makes me question swimming :S. I’ll have to stay on the sand and eat all the picnic goodies.

Can we talk about these whoopie pies – – YUUUUMMM!!

Jen @ Jen

S’mores week is going strong! I think this one is my favorite!

Hahaha, this was a great post – not too bratty, but just enough! 😉 It’s okay to vent a little sometimes, after all – it’s your blog! I definitely understand where you’re coming from, though I’m guilty of not always reading posts myself. I don’t however, not read posts, but then comment on them. I tend to be a lurker – following tons of blogs and posts and commenting rarely. But here I am… trying new things. We’ll see if I can keep it up, because I do like the opportunity to take a moment to say: These whoopie pies… Read more »

I really like your blog! These smores whoopie pies look so good.


I have been drooling over these since you posted a picture on instagram the other day. I think I must make them… As for reading your posts. I can’t visit you without reading. Your writing is what snagged me in the first place. The first post of yours I ever read was the one with “Sherry” and I think it was a Reese’s recipe. I damn near peed my pants I was laughing so hard. Anyway, I was hooked. Keep writing and I’ll keep reading!

Now, I may be new to posting comments on here, but I do follow your blog. And I don’t bake/cook/use any utensils in the kitchen. Therefore, I read for your wittiness and wonderful posts. I also read for your pictures that make me drool and super cool ideas. However, looking back to the smore’s cupcakes, I noticed that 23 out of 47 of your posts was actually about the story you wrote (boob grazing anyone?). So, HALF of your comments are about your stories. So, I don’t think people are only going on your website just to skim that stuff… Read more »

So we are going to the ocean in 2 weeks, and now all I can think about i getting attacked by electric eels.But think of how much you can save on your electric bill!

cindy p

i always (well mostly) read your posts! ….but your pictures are SO GOOD that sometimes i am not patient enough to read anything else, ’till i see how you’ve created that latest bit o’ sugar magic!!! …kinda like skipping dinner and diving right into the dessert…..do you blame me? well, thanks for your awesome sweets….and for making me laugh once in a while…..you print what i think and it makes me feel a little less bratty, myself. 😉


Thanks for the food porn! I think you should suggest the electric eel idea to the DEP!

Carla Yielding

I NEVER skim your blog (just saying…) 🙂 Your witty words are whatyou make it so entertaining! I can get good recipes from lots of sources but I love yours the best cause they always make me giggle in some way. Must be your “electric” personality! Ha

Aimee @ ShugarySweets

Sometimes the imaginary sugar high from your photos clogs my vision and all I can see are sugar plums dancing in my head and I suddenly think, “santa is that you???” Hey if you’re electric you may also be santa.

Any who….the whoopie pies look amazing! Of course!

Danielle Goewert

SO FUNNY!! I love anything Smores:) Thanks for the great post I do love them and read them;)

true story i have never had a smore – i don’t know what they taste like – but i know that i want these in and around my mouth! marshmallow buttercream! are you trying to give me a panic attack with excitement – like wow! also i would like to be electric i think the first thing i would do would be buy and electric car then never charge it! then no one could steal it! ha! what was the first thing you did with your electric finger? did you pretend you were ET? that would also be cool. does… Read more »

Dude, I WISH I could light my home with the touch of an electric finger! That would be rad.
I think these whoopie pies will be rad too. 🙂


You may be able to power your house with your finger, but we both know I am the Golden Child (TM). Look for the trilogy soon. I’ll be eating all of your awesome recipes that I make as I create the masterpiece.


I always read your posts; you always make me laugh, except when you are being bratty….just kidding..lol These S’mores look great:)

Carol Milliron (@millic)
Carol Milliron (@millic)

I would love to hang out with you at a party, and not just because I think you’d bring good treats, but because I really enjoy the way you write. Gooey pictures with a side of snarkiness and a glass of milk? Yes please!


i always read your posts! you are so freaking hilarious! and everything you make always looks so delicious! 🙂 thanks for the entertainment!


I for one love your posts, and I bought a whoopie pan last year, so I am going to try these wonderfully delicious whoopie pies. Now you made me hungry to try these. And to try out my new pan again, I only used it one time, and now I am going for 2x’s, thank you for the post on this flavor of whoopi pies. Love it…

Heather (Heather

i am literally trying to lick the screen!


Eels freak me out and I avoid going into any body of water where there are things that might want to bite me. I cringe whenever I watch The Princess Bride and she gets brushed in the water by the shreaking eels.

I’m so making these for our office afternoon treat cart.


You are one of the few blogs I don’t skim, but actually read through. cause you are just hi-fricken-larous

So is it horrible that when I got to the eel part I got the song “Electric slide” stuck in my head. Do do do do do do do It’s electric…


Number 1 I love everything s’more so you’re making this the best birthday week ever! Number 2 we just did a biology project in my lab at ASU and poop is EVERYWHERE 🙁 sorry If that just ruined your life.

Katrina @ Warm Vanilla Sugar

These are fabulous! Awesome idea!


No way – an electric eel – way cool!! This recipe looks ridiculously delicious !

Crystal River

ok, I will admitt I have skipped the full read sometimes but dang thats your fault for posting such yummy pictures that make me wanna get right to the recipe. Like this one today!
so keep up the good work and the awesome pics too! YUMMY!


I’m probably old enough to be your mama and am out of your demographic, but I discovered you a couple of months ago and am enjoying your bog. I read your entire posts!! For real!! Example, I don’t care for S’mores because I don’t like marshmallows (kinda makes me gag with all that white fluffiness), but I read your entire post anyway. Soooo….don’t cry darlin”. You have fans who read everything.

Erin @ Texanerin Baking
Ooh… that drives me crazy. There’s this one person who is obviously subscribed to hundreds of blogs and leaves comments on basically every new post. Very standard comments. – You were in the hospital for a week and almost died? “Those look yummy! I have to make these!” – Your puppy was run over last night? “Wow! I can’t wait to make these!” – You found out you have cancer? “Great recipe! Will try later!” I wonder if she has a file and just copies and pastes these things. Ehem. Anyway, I don’t like smores or whoopie pies but I… Read more »
Tracy {Pale Yellow}

I love your schmearing technique, very nice. I’m glad I made a new Pinterest board yesterday exclusively for whoopie pies, these gorgeous girls will fit right in.

Melissa @ Treats With a Twist

That cracked me up because it’s definitely the things I’m thinking without saying. I laughed my ass off at the fear of grazing the pedicurists’ boobs on your previous post by the way. I thought about it and it made me smile for hours afterwards. Just so you know 🙂


I enjoy what you write at least as much as the dessert, if not more. Although please don’t graze my boob….And I agree about the ocean.


I’m glad I’m not the only one who fears the ocean. Don’t get me wrong, I love being near it and listening to the waves…but going inside where all the THINGS are that brush up against your leg as soon as you’re not paying attention? No way.

These pies are so adorable, I’ve been loving your s’mores week!!


1. Again– you’re photos are so lovely! Sometimes I can’t stop looking.

2. I’m also super impressed with the genius of this dessert.

3. I may not ever leave a comment inviting you to graze my boob, but yours is one of the few blogs that I actually do read instead of simply doing the “drool and pin.”



*also I can spell “your.” Not sure what happened there.

Liz @ Tip Top Shape

These look amazing!!!!!

Tara @ secretsofamomaholic.com

So funny- I love your stories & just browse your baked goods because I cant bake for shit! I wish I could- but it’s just NOT in me.

Your story is what got me to follow you the very first time I read one of your posts!
I would be disappointed if you just posted your recipe & not a story!

Jen of My Tiny Oven

Your posts are the one thing that make me smile while I am toiling away at work all day!
Yes, your recipes are always ridiculously awesome, but Iam here for my laugh out loud moment of the day! Thanks for that!!


You make me laugh! And for a second I definitely was like “eels can’t really make you electric, can they?” I won’t lie, I was a little concerned for your well-being. God forbid you were so afflicted with your electricity, you couldn’t post tasty treats. = )

I always ALWAYS read what you write! Don’t hate me, but I’ll admit that sometimes I don’t actually read the recipes. I always go through the step-by-step, but I have an irrational fear that once I read the recipe I’m going to go “that’s too easy NOT to make” and make them and then eat them all and when I weigh 1200 pounds I’ll have to tell my doctor that it’s your fault and then you’d be in trouble. So really it’s to your benefit that I skip the recipe part. And also, I have them delivered to my inbox… Read more »

I’m a horrible follower/reader 🙁 I love what you write, it’s hilarious and I’m not just saying that because I want you to become my personal baker! I actually think you’re one of the funniest bloggers. I’ve also pinned near everything you’ve made. I think I’m obsessed 🙁


OK, you’ve got me drooling on the keyboard again. This is genius and as far as I’m concerned it was YOUR idea because I saw it here first …lol.

I do read your posts. I think they’re hilarious, and I really hope you’re not going to take that lady up on her offer. It was kind of her to want to help you, but I think it might just creep you out further.

Keep the s’mores coming!

Snoopy 😀


Truthfully I always read the whole post for the day, even if I’m not interested in the recipe. You crack me up. Yes enough to graze a boob.


I love all of the s’mores desserts lately!


I have celiac disease so I have to be gluten free and can’t eat the majority of your recipes. However, I’m always super excited when you have a new post – your stories make me smile every time 🙂