Candy Pie

How was your Thanksgiving?  Are you full?

I actually ate more the day AFTER Thanksgiving than on the day itself.  I feel like I let my guard down, thought I had Thanksgiving topped.  I got cocky.

We are lucky enough to to have great friends and neighbors and the day after Thanksgiving we have “Friendsgiving”.  Well, I was weak.  I made and ate THIS and THIS and my friend made THESE and I all but licked the bowl clean.

I woke up Saturday morning telling myself I would only drink water until Christmas.  It took me ’til about…say…9:30 am until I was back on food.  I told you I was weak.

MY OTHER RECIPES

You wanna know what happened?  Pie.  Actually pudding pie.

I am not a pudding person.  I have never been a pie person. Soooo, when I decided to make this I knew I wouldn’t be tempted.

I am wrong a lot.

Here’s the thing about this pie…it’s the pudding.

When I said I am not a pudding person that is true.  I don’t like making it, I don’t like the texture, I don’t like the taste.

WELLLLLL, I had never made homemade pudding.

Life changer, people.  Life.  Changer.

Here’s what you need to know about this Candy Pie:

  • Oreo crust?  Check.
  • Homemade chocolate pudding?  Check.
  • Milky Way?  Check.
  • Reese’s Cups?  Check.
  • Marshmallows?  Check
  • Brownies?  Check.
  • Whipped cream?  Check.
  • M&M’s?  Check.

Do I have your attention?  All of those ingredients rock my world…but it’s the pudding people…make it.

 

First make your Oreo crust, or use a store bought if you want…but they’re really easy.  Just mash up some Oreos and mix with melted butter and press into a pie pan and bake.

Now, also, if you are feeling all “make-from-scratchy” go ahead and bake up some brownies.  Whatever kind you like.  If not, use store bought brownies.  It really won’t make too much of a difference.

Next, make your pudding.  Again, if you are really not into it, you can certainly use a boxed pudding mix, but I urge you to make the pudding.

While your pudding is cooling chop up you Milky Way and brownies.  Spread them on top of your Oreo crust.

Then mix your Reese’s and marshmallows into your cooled pudding.

Pour this deliciousness on top of your Milky Way and brownies.  Chill the pie for 3 hours.

Then when you are ready to serve, spread some whipped cream on top, again, either homemade or store-bought, and sprinkle some M&Ms on, because they’re pretty.

Now, I dare you not to stand over the pie plate and eat it with a spoon.  I straight-up dare you.

MAKE THE PUDDING!

Print

Candy Pie


Ingredients

Crust

  • 20 Oreos, crushed
  • 2 Tbsp butter, melted
  • 2 Tbsp milk

Filling

  • 3/4 cup sugar
  • 3 1/2 Tbsp cornstarch
  • 1/8 tsp salt
  • 2 1/2 cups whole milk
  • 4 egg yolks
  • 2 Tbsp butter
  • 2 tsp vanilla
  • 3 oz unsweetened chocolate, chopped
  • 1/2 cup Mini Reese’s Cups or 1/2 cup chopped full size Reese’s
  • 1/2 cup mini marshmallows
  • 1/3 cup chopped Milky Way bars (approx 1 bar)
  • 1/3 cup chopped brownies (either store-bought or homemade)

Topping

  • 2 cups Whipped Cream (homemade or whipped topping)
  • 1/3 cup M&M’s

Instructions

  1. Crust
  2. Heat oven to 350°.
  3. Mix your Oreos and melted butter together and press into a 9-inch pie plate. Bake 5 minutes. Remove from oven and cool on wire rack.

Filling

  1. In a medium sauce pan whisk together sugar, cornstarch and salt. Whisk in milk and egg yolks until well combined. Place saucepan over medium heat, whisking constantly. When mixture comes to a boil, add butter, 1 tablespoon at a time and vanilla. Next add the chocolate a little at a time and whisk until melted. When melted and smooth, remove from heat. Let cool for 10 – 15 minutes and then fold in your Reese’s and marshmallows.
  2. Layer your crust with your Milky Way and brownies and then pour pudding mixture on top of that. Cover pie tightly with plastic wrap and place in refrigerator for at least 3 hours.
  3. When ready to serve, remove the plastic wrap and spread your whipped topping or whipped cream on the pudding. Garnish with your M&Ms.
  4. Serve cold.

Notes

You can use a store-bought crust, boxed pudding and store-bought brownies if you prefer.

Recipe adapted from: Perfect Pies

 

 

Contest runs  through Sunday, December 4th at 11:59 pm and is open to US and Canada residents only.

 CONTEST CLOSED

1583 Responses

  1. I’ve had more desserts since Thanksgiving too! It suddenly became imperative Friday night to make a truffle cake, and that turned out to be a brilliant ideal.

    I was going to buy a KitchenAid this weekend, but my house got robbed this week and I’ve got to save my cash for re-buying my life, so… winning would be fabulous!

    French silk pie is my favorite!

  2. Christina

    I like pies, but I’m really more of a tart fan, something about pie crust just doesn’t make me feel very excited…but I got a soft spot of cherry pie… Yummmm!

  3. Michele

    My favorite pie has to be lemon cream or meringue …… so comforting and just the right amount of tart and sweet. Brings me back to being 8 years old again ! Thank you for your thoughtfulness in offering such a wonderful gift…. I have my grandmothers and after almost 35 years of baking it is losing it’s edge.

  4. Gail

    Gonna have to try this pie–it has all my favorite candy in it…However, I am gaining weight just reading the recipe….This looks so go, it probably ought to be illegal!!

  5. Mmmm…. favorite pie is my Grandma’s home-made apple pie with a slice of american cheese melted on top with a scoop of home-made vanilla ice cream! YUMMEROOS!

  6. Shelley

    My favorite pie is Kalhua Cream pie….but I’m thinking after trying this candy pie it may move above as my favorite on my list 😉 Yum!!

  7. Lori Lamb

    This is a must make at my Daughters for Christmas this year! My grandsons will love it, and with Grandma there, she says “yes you can have more honey” !

  8. I’m the only one in my family that loves pie! MMMmmm! I have very fond memories of my Grandma’s fresh blueberry pie and there’s nothing like homemade apple pie, but I think my very favourite is old fashioned Lemon Meringue Pie. Yum!
    (I’m thinking with that Candy Pie Recipe I may be able to convert my kids and hubby to pies!)

  9. Erica

    This pie is…amazing! I can’t wait to try it out on the family when I get moved to my new place. Although my next home is temporary until I find something permanent, I still plan to get all my kitchen stuff unpacked and be making lots of goodies for Christmas. I think this pie will be well-loved by my sweet-toothed family members back home! =)

  10. Andrea McIntyre

    I just made a chocolate dream pie for Thanksgiving, but now I must make this one!!! Anything with an Oreo crust and added chocolate is a keeper!! And the Kitchen Aid would be an added bonus! 🙂

  11. Mary

    Buttermilk Pie is my favorite. I am diabetic and now need a shot of insulin …. and that is just from reading the recipe. I have all the ingredients and this is being made for my Grand Kids. Boy, will they love me more and their parents, a little less. I bake for my Hubby and everyone else…..love the sharing part of cooking and a Kitchen Aid mixer would sure make everything much easier. Thanks for such a great blog!

  12. Laurieann Tobias

    It’s was a toss up between apple pie with a crumb topping and chocolate pudding pie smothered in whipped cream… now, after reading your blog on the Candy Pie I’m kinda thinking I may have a new ultimate favorite, thank you for sharing.

  13. Caroline Gallant

    It’s a toss up between Lemon Meringue and Grasshopper Pie!! Lemon Meringue is more of my go-to summer pie because i find it so refreshing, but my Great Aunt always made Grasshopper pie for everyone during the holidays… chocolate and mint with a dollop of whipped cream on top? who can say no to that?!?!!?

  14. Sara

    My favorite pie isn’t so much a pie as it is a pie/cobbler- It’s a fresh berry pie with whisky and a sweet biscuit crust- so good

  15. Heather Honnoll

    This pie looks sinfully delicious! My favorite pie is a toss up between chocolate meringue pie with graham cracker crust and my aunt’s blueberry pie. Soooo good.

  16. KC Harrington

    Your post made me chuckle. I swore I wouldn’t have anything but water until Christmas, too – well, I decided water AND coffee! I think it only took me until about 8:45 a.m.! At any rate, the pie looks great! Looking forward to making treats for my son who becomes a U.S. Marine this week!

  17. Jennifer Monroe

    Ok, i am making my grocery list out as we speak and going to the market to pick up everything to make the pie you listed above.. my children will forever love you and so will i!!!
    I have to say after all these years of being a cheesecake fanatic i was asked to make a Lemon Chess Pie for a friends Thanksgiving dinner and i have to admit that it is now my favorite that is maybe until i make this Candy Pie tonight!!

  18. I love making pie. When I was in college, baking became a stress reliever for me, so every Saturday morning I would get up at dawn (long before my roommates) and start making dough from scratch, using Grandma’s recipe. I’d roll out two crusts, dice up whatever fruit was in season, and either do a lattice top, a crumble top or a cut out top, depending on my mood, and bake them.

    A few hours later, I’d show up on the doorstep of my best guy friend’s apartment and pound on their door until one of the boys dragged himself out of bed to collect two fresh out of the oven pies. They quickly learned that if they returned my pie pans by the next weekend, the whole scenario would repeat itself, and enjoyed pie for breakfast every weekend for an entire year.

  19. Amanda

    This looks simply heavenly. My favorite pie is a toss up between peanut butter pie and coconut cream. Heck, who am I kidding, I love ALL pies!

  20. Megan Tracey

    All time favorite pie is peanut butter pie with a honemade (which in my world means extra oreos, and a little bit rougher chop) Oreo crust…..how could anyone not love that!!! Except for peanut allergy people, but everyone else, YES!!

  21. Fran P.

    My favorite pie is Swiss chocolate (or French Silk, whichever you prefer – I just know that it’s chocolate & sugar & eggs all whipped up and it’s wicked good!!!) 🙂

  22. Oh that isn’t pie, that is heaven in a pan! I think it would be an instant hit here, so I refuse to try it! Oh and if I got a big kitchen aid like that, I would make it once, just to say thanks.

  23. Becca

    Well, my favorite pie would be any one with the word “pie” in it. But i do limit myself, I only eat it on the days ending in “be y “.

  24. gamms

    OH EM GEE, this pie looks crazy good.
    My fav pie, my mother’s oh so secret recipe…passed on only after exacting an oath never to divulge it outside the family under threat of death and/or dismemberment…needless to say my family is a bit dramatic. 🙂

  25. Michelle Rodriguez

    My favorite pie is a little bit embarrassing …. chocolate pudding pie. Pudding from the cook & serve box, frozen Ritz crust! I know, I know, horendous.

  26. Amy C

    So far, my favorite pie is your Reese’s Fudge Pie. Oh. My. Goodness. My friend Edie made it for me, and I just about died and went to heaven! I know what you mean about fruit pies. Not a fan. But I love this pie! Oh, and the new peanut butter pie I made this year for Thanksgiving that apparently no one thought they would like (except for me) but was the only pie that was completely gone!! My family should know by now to trust my tastebuds! Love your site!!

  27. That looks amazing! I loved your comment about eating more after Thanksgiving because you let your guard down. That about summed up my Thanksgiving as well!

    My favorite pie is a warm peach pie topped with vanilla bean ice cream. Makes me think of summer!

    Awesome giveaway! Thanks!!

  28. Marci Johnson

    ohhhhhh I would love this mixer!!!! And I could make my favorite pie in it- lemon meringue…. I bet this mixer could whip up some perfect meringue in no time at all….. 🙂

  29. Renee

    Being from Louisiana, my favorite pie has to be a southern tradition. My fave is pecan pie. Love. Fresh warm pecan pie with a tall glass of milk. Yum-o!

  30. Marilyn

    I want one SO bad!!! White is the color I need too. OK. My pie would be chocolate. My mother in law taught me how to make it. You use dove chocolate and marshmallow meringue. Oh, it is wonderful.

  31. Candace

    I absolutely love reading your blog!!
    I made 5 pies for thanksgiving this year, because 6 would have been just too many. My favorite was key lime. Ya know, very traditional.

  32. Here is my comment….and I soooo need that mixer for baking class next semester!
    As for my favorite pie? It would be chicken pot pie but since I believe you meant sweet that would be blackberry pie! Oh you’ve got me excited thinking about pies and breads and cakes and that wonderful mixer! Thank you

  33. Stefania Ferrandino

    Hands down my favorite pie is butterscotch pie! I’m not a pie person either but butterscotch pie is always a winner although your amazing Candy Pie might win me some brownie points with the kiddies! I got a toothache just reading the ingredients, yum. That glorious mixer to replace my chintzy handheld mixer would just be the cream on top of the pie! Me & my smoking burning handheld mixer motor would be most grateful!

  34. Jacinta

    Chocolate Silk Mousse Pie. Although, if I had all the ingredients I would be making the pie in this post right now!

    PS: I love that this contest is open to Canadians! Yay!

  35. Debbie Wydick

    PIES!!!!!!! Who doesn’t love em?? I am the pie baker in my fam. And that is ok….cause I love my homemade crust recipe the best. I would have to say….and it is a hard decision to make….that Strawberry Rhubarb is my FAV! But just about any is ok with me.

  36. Jean Badgley

    I am not sure if I have ever NOT liked a pie…but if I HAD to choose a favorite..it would be my Mom’s choc chunk pie…a lot of work but very very very good.

  37. Becca Taylor

    Pie is probably my favorite dessert form so its hard to choose just one, but currently I’m dreaming of a warm, chocolately, nutty, and creamy Derby Pie!!

  38. amanda

    Ok, so I AM a pudding person AND a pie person, so my favorite pie has always been chocolate pudding pie with a graham cracker crust and whipped topping, or if I’m feeling frisky, meringue. And recently, while perusing the pioneer woman archives I stumbled upon her Pots de Creme recipe. Slapped me some of that in a store bought graham cracker crust topped it with cool whip, and THAT ladies and gents is my version of a ‘grown up’ chocolate pudding pie. It is SO good!

  39. Michelle White

    Any pie that involves chocolate and peanut butter will not stand a chance in my house. That being said I love making pies especially since I use my Mamaw’s recipes and get requests for them all the time!
    Thanks for the giveaway. I have wanted one of those mixers for years!
    Michelle W.

  40. Treya

    My favorite pie is cheesecake! I made two oversized mocha cheesecakes for Thanksgiving, and smartly gave all but 4 pieces away 😉

    A kitchen aid has been on my list for YEARS! I’ve started a sort of bakery out of my house and this would be insanely helpful!

  41. Tiffany McDonald

    My favorite pie is raspberry cream from this local bakery by my house!!! It has a layer of a custard cream a layer of raspberry filling and topped with whipped cream… Yum. Running a close second is coconut cream!!

  42. Dana

    My favorite is Peanut Butter Pie with Oreo crust and fudge topping…mmm…but I’m thinking your Candy Pie could be stiff competition! I’ll have to give it a try! Thanks for the great giveaway!

  43. Janet

    I love a good apple pie! My tried and tested apple pie comes from Martha Stewart! It is amazing! I had it from somewhere else, but it can be found in her book pies and tarts!

  44. Stephanie E.

    I must say your pudding pie looks tasty! The pie for me would have to be a french silk pie. Just a sliver because of how gloriously rich it is. Wonderful give away!

  45. Julie

    My all-time favorite pie is lemon ice box! I would love, love, love to win this mixer – thank you (and Webstaurant) for the opportunity!

  46. I really dislike fruit pies, cooked warm fruit doesn’t do it for me. But I do love custard pies coconut cream along with peanut pies are my favorite!!
    I would love to have a kitchen aid to aid (pun intended) me in the kitchen!!

  47. Amy H.

    Pie, Pie
    Me oh my
    Nothing tastes sweet, wet, salty and dry
    all at once o well it’s pie
    Apple!
    Pumpkin!
    Minced
    an’ wet bottom.
    Come to your place everyday if you’ve got em’
    Pie
    Me o my
    I love pie 🙂

    I love Grasshopper Pie!

  48. Lisa L.

    Making that pie tonight as soon as the kids are down! SO glad I have all the ingredients on hand (thank you Halloween basket!) What a wonderful giveaway– thank you for the chance to win. My favorite pie is Grasshopper pie! So good!! 🙂

  49. I love candy, so your pie might just be my favorite! But since I haven ‘t tried yours YET – I’d have to say grasshopper pie.

    Wonderful giveaway! I’ll be sharing with my peeps. 🙂

  50. Janet

    I don’t see my post? I love apple pie! Martha Stewart has one of the best recipes in her pies and tarts book! I really would love to win this!

  51. rebecca

    WOW! ok, that candy pie looks soooo good! but, still, my most favorite pie will always and forever be blueberry! MMMMMMMMM! BLUEBERRRRY! 😀

  52. Helene Mahnken

    First, I am a firm believer in pies coming in graham cracker and/or cookie crusts… Yum. 🙂

    Second, my favorite is probably peanut butter nutella. 🙂

  53. Morgan

    My favorite pie is a triple layer pumpkin pie- it sounds very odd but it makes use of pumpkin spice pudding, french vanilla whip cream, caramel, and pumpkin! It is beyond delightful and a nice light, fluffy twist on the original (although from this description, certainly doesn’t sound too light).

  54. OMG! I have wanted a kitchen aid for years and just have not been able to afford one, would love to win this giveaway. I love your blog and my favorite pie has to be chocolate cream.

  55. Haikus to my favorite pie: chocolate salted carmel. mmmmm…..

    The chocolate crust,
    it is so perfectly sweet,
    not soggy, not dry,

    a really nice treat.
    More chocolate on top, and
    fleur de sel as well,

    meet the caramel
    to create a heavenly
    smell and taste and, and….

    OH! NO! It is gone
    already? But I never,
    I never, got to

    describe the perfect
    feeling it gives me inside
    to taste this pie is

    a really nice treat.
    Really perfect, so perfect,
    I’m melting inside.

  56. I’ve heard it called Derby pie, but basically it’s pecan pie with chocolate in it. I love it. I love it so much I ate the whole thing by myself since Thanksgiving, I have one piece left and I’m eating it tonight then it’s nothing but water til Christmas. 😉

  57. Jen

    Pumpkin pie is my favorite! Although I tried shoo-fly pie once in Pennsylvania years ago, and that is a close second. AND my little hand-mixer could use an upgrade. 🙂

  58. Kimberly

    My favorite pie is pecan. I put pecans in almost everything. I am getting ready to make your peanut butter fudge pie because what is life without peanut butter? Had to get springform pans, but I am rarin’ to go. Happy Holidays!

  59. Nelcha

    mmmm I LOVE APPLE PIE!! It reminds me of when my mother would take us out and help her pick apples. What I wouldn’t give to go pick apples with her again.

  60. Aubrie

    Wow, that pie looks sinful! My current favorite pie is a chocolate-nutella pudding pie. When I made it for the first time last month, it was my first time making homemade pudding too and I totally agree with you–life changing!

  61. Courtney Martin

    What an amazing giveaway! I have been dyingggg for a KitchenAid! My favorite pie is actually chocolate pudding pie so I am so excited to try this amped up version of it especially since it includes all of my favorite things! You are fantastic!

  62. Carley

    My favorite pie is a pie my mom makes, it’s called “Guy Pie” and it is a combination of a banana cream, coconut cream, and chocolate cream pie (it also has homemade chocolate pudding in it)!!!! It is sooooo good!

  63. Cathy

    My favorite pie is chocolate pie with cool whip topping 🙂 Thanks so much for the opportunity to win a mixer, it would be AMAZING. I have just started to really get into baking and I can only imagine it would make things much easier!

  64. Peach pie (with fresh peaches!), followed by apple pie with dried cherries – I love Ina Garten’s recipe for this!
    I would love love love to have this stand mixer – it would be perfect for the dozens of sugar cookies we make around Christmas time 🙂 Thanks for hosting such a great giveaway!

  65. Paige

    Pie. Any kind. Any day. I love ALL kinds….but am drooling over your pictures! My MIL makes one with bananas and pudding with the Nilla Wafer crust, though it’s not a banana cream. To die for!

  66. Diane Schultz

    Apple pie is my favorite but it has to be made by my mom and served warm, right out of the oven. I make very good pies but the pie’s made by my mom are always the best! Mom uses lard and love!

  67. My favorite pie would have to be the simple pudding pie my grandmother always made. just a graham cracker crust with 3 layers of thick pudding, vanilla (bottom), butterscotch (middle), and chocolate (top). Such a basic concept but so delicious!

    p.s. I ADORE Webstaurant Store, that site Rocks! I cannot say enough about their products (and pricing) and I get my orders extemely fast. Love Them!!!

  68. Mindy

    The Webstaurant Store people are the best! (Hi, Steven!) And I sure would love a new KitchenAid. Almost as much as I love pecan pie, or key lime pie. I can’t choose between the two!

  69. Kathy Fry

    Yum!! This pie looks very interesting. My favorite pie is peanut butter. I also like to use the Oreo crust for my peanut butter pies.

  70. Amanda Mac

    Hmmm… I’m not typically a huge pie fan, but if I had to pick a favorite, it would probably be my mom’s strawberry pie (which is really more like a cobbler, but she calls it pie, so that counts, right?)

  71. Maggie

    This is a toss up because pie is just so good! My favorites are chocolate, pecan, and peanut butter. Or any combination of the three will do 🙂

  72. Jodi McKinney

    Love you blog. This looks yummy! My family loves all my pies – maybe dutch apple the best. Pumpkin for Thanksgiving. Peach in the summer. Can’t wait to try this. Thanks for sharing!

  73. Oh my goodness! What a generous giveaway!!

    I am a pie person. I love it in all it’s forms but my favorites are classics like blueberry, apple and lemon meringue. If I had to choose my #1 favorite, it would be apple.

  74. I’d have to say banana cream. But I’m the only one in my house who likes it, and it doesn’t look awesome after the first day because the bananas get brown, so I don’t get it often enough!

  75. Kelly

    My favorite pie is strawberry chiffon, or better known to my friends as pink pie.
    I am a Baking student, and asked for a KitchenAid for the holidays last year. I got one all right… It fit in the palm of my hand, and looks very nice with the rest of the ordainments hanging on my tree. 🙂

  76. CJ

    GREAT giveaway! I would give this as a gift to someone I know that reallllllly wants a KitchenAid but doesn’t have the means to get one for herself. My favorite pie – sigh – the Butterscotch Meringue pie that my mom used to make. She never wrote it down that I know of. My sister and I have tried to duplicate it – TRIED.

  77. Micaela

    You actually want me to choose my *favorite* pie? That’s like choosing a favorite child… I don’t… geez, there are like 5 pies tied for 1st place! Triple Berry pie/cherry pie/Sour cream apple pie/sweet potato pie/Marionberry pie.

  78. Lin

    My great-grandma’s Sugar Pie!

    Crossing every finger & every toe that I’m chosen. Hasn’t been a very good year and baking makes me happy. This Kitchen

  79. Lin

    My great-grandma’s Sugar Pie!

    Crossing every finger & every toe that I’m chosen. Hasn’t been a very good year and baking makes me happy. This Kitchen Aid stand mixer would make my holiday very jolly!

  80. My favorite pie? Hum…I have 2! The first is my grandmother’s chocolate mousse that I make into a chocolate mousse pie in an Oreo crust with cool whip on top! The 2nd would be my caramel apple pie. BTW, I can’t wait to try this Candy Pie…but I have to find a reason to make it (such as a party or company coming over) or I’ll end up eating the whole thing myself, lol.

  81. Sheryl Hoyt

    My Mom is the best pie baker, it’s hard to pick a favorite, her rhubarb pie. apple pie & pecan pie are really yummy & they are always picture perfect…I was a lucky kid! I would LOVE to win a KitchenAid!!!

  82. Julie Cannon

    Love your website My favorite pins. Really need the mixer, too. My daughter has a great mixer and I only have an old cheapo. Mixer envy like mad! Favorite pie: Pecan Pie–I’m a true southern girl

  83. Lora Mallory

    I’m not a pie person either, so I don’t really have a favorite – like baking them, not eating them. I’m a cheesecake gal!

  84. Amanda

    My favorite pie is definitely the old goodie, pumpkin pie. But last year, for a friend’s birthday, we made a pumple cake. Pumpkin pie inside a chocolate cake layer, apple pie inside a yellow cake layer. All frosted with cream cheese frosting. Ridiculous. I saw a cherpumple recently that added a cherry pie/spice cake layer. It might be on my “to do” list. I didn’t know anything to match the decadence of these ridiculous pie/cake monstrosities, but this pie you showed just might. oh. my. goodness!!

  85. My favorite pie is a Flapper Pie. My family has made this recipe for years and years. It has been passed down through the family and we make it for special occasions~ We just made it for our Thanksgiving Feast. It is a homemade custard pie with a graham cracker crust. mmmmmmmm

  86. This would be the best present ever! My favorite pie is lemon merigue pie…not ever one makes it good…its usually too tart but i get some at one pie shop that is perfect. If i won this mixer i could make my own. I also love a good pumpkin pie. Thanks for this awesome giveaway
    Hugs deb

  87. Colleen Hoffman

    I love a good peanut butter pie. I love a good chocolate pie. I love oreo crusted pies. I love a pie with ice cream in it. I could go for pie with whipped cream top – or the bottom – or the middle, lol.

  88. Ali

    I would LOVE to win this Kitchenaid!!! My favorite pie….let’s see…that’s probably chocolate chess!! or maybe PB ice cream pie…they are both very yummy!!!

    Ali

  89. Great blog! A Kitchen Aid is a must have for everyone. There are lots of great things to make at home this holiday season! We sell a fantastic Brownie Mix on our website at http://www.chocmo.com/products/artisan-brownie-mix That’s what I’ll be using the new mixer for if I win…. Btw, if anybody reads this post and wants to order the mix, put “$1 off Cookiesandcups.com” in the comments field and I’ll take $1 off your order.

  90. Kathryn

    My favorite pie is my mom’s apple pie. I’ve had others and NOTHING comes close to hers! If I’m making a pie, def have to have chocolate cream pie! With homemade pudding! Yummm!

  91. Ilene

    I was never a pie person until I had “Aunt Shirley’s” pecan pie. Aunt Shirley was on my husband’s side of the family. He has no idea how he’s related to her, but he’ll eat only her pecan pie. According to him, nothing else measures up. This year, dare I say, I made it BETTER. That’s right. My new favorite pie is dark chocolate pecan pie. Hells yeah.

  92. pam

    i make a oreo cake with oreo bottom then chocolate pudding, vanilla pudding coolwhip and then chopped oreo chocolate syrup and nut on top yours sound so good i am going to have make

  93. MARLYS Folly

    My favorite all time pie has to be pumpkin…. although like most fruit pies. But this candy pie looks delicious and will have to try it.

  94. Oh Dear God. I think I have died and gone to heaven! Candy Pie??? Really? It is now my favorite! The only thing that would make heaven better is to have that mixer with me!

  95. Ashley M

    So my favorite pie has to be pecan…but it looks like this candy pie might give my pecan pie a run for its money. Next trip to the store I am picking up these ingredients and giving it a try!!

  96. My favorite pie… Well, chocolate cream of course. Followed closely by lemon meringue. Then there was that peanut butter pie I made last month. Is cheesecake considered pie? I can’t decide. It might become this one when I make it. No fruit for me, please. Just sugar.

  97. Gigi

    Coconut mousse pie is definitely my hands down winner…but sadly I don’t have the recipe…it’s on the dessert menu of a local restaurant…if I can’t get my hands on a slice of that, pecan or buttermilk pies will have to do….

  98. Lauren

    oh my god, that looks insane. i’m drooling.

    i’m definitely more of a pie fan than a cake fan. i like fruity pies, but generally end up leaving the rest of the crust. i like chocolate mousse because there’s no crust (or if it is, it’s something yummy like oreos)!

  99. FillyFolly

    Nothing beats a perfect Lemon Merengue pie in the Summer, and a Pumpkin Pie in the Fall. I have been pining after a Kitchen Aid for a few years, they never seem to be on sale enough for me to spring for one.

  100. Donna

    I love pie…period! Banana cream, lemon meringue, apple, pecan, chocolate. I just love pie! It depends on the season and my mood. Thanks for this great giveaway!

  101. Leslie

    I am not a huge pie fan but I do love French Silk Pie and even love making it. Just set the current mixer to whip and stand back for five minutes re-reading Hunger Games. Yum.

  102. Jodi Mason

    My grandmother was an excellent baker everyone loved her pies. But the one fruit pie I like is peach pie. But I llike allmost any cream pie.

  103. Stacy

    My favorite pie is apple pie (with crumble topping, of course!) What a fantastic giveaway! I definitely need this-my poor kitchen aid no longer has 10 speeds, just basically on and off. 🙁

    Stacy

  104. sabine henning

    my favorite pie is “Banana Toffee Pie”. just amazing!!!
    but this pie here looks great. i think my oreos are ready!!! mmmh! 😀

  105. Belladatura

    Mmmm, pie. I love pie, but I’m sort of a purist, so I’m going to go with apple as my favorite. Don’t worry – it will change tomorrow. 🙂

  106. I have wanted a Kitchen Aid for years so this year I put this model on my Christmas list, O how I need one so badly. I love pie and have many favorites but lemon meringue would be #1 on my list. I must give this candy pie a try it looks and sounds delish!!!

  107. Jenni K

    This summer I made a fresh strawberry pie from strawberries I had picked that morning with my daughter. I have to say, I used to think I was a pumpkin, or cheesecake, or french silk kind of girl. That strawberry pie shot to the top of my list. I can’t wait for next summer. 🙂 PS – I am DYING for a KitchenAid mixer. I have been drooling over them in every ad, and dropping not-so-subtle hints to my husband for a while. This would make my year.

  108. baking for years with nothing but brute strength and a handmixer makes for amazingly toned arms. wish my baked goods would reflect the beautifulness that is my sculpted limbs! standmixer appreciated!!

  109. Maureen Chapman

    My favorite pies are my grandma’s Lemon Meringue and Chocolate Meringue, both made completely from scratch just like my grandma used to make(rip Grandma). I make them just like she did!! And my Aunt’s apple pie. Simply amazing!!

  110. Shanea

    Favorite Pie: Cheaters banana cream pie.

    pre-made nilla wafer crust
    layer of sliced bananas
    make up a box of banana cream pudding and mix with half a tub of cool whip,
    then another layer of sliced bananas. Delicious!!!

  111. Breanna

    oh myyy goodness, that candy pie is definitely a new addition to my recipe list. Id say my favorite pie is my daddy’s good old apple pie with the struesel topping, fresh out of the oven with a big scoop of vanilla ice cream. mmmmm! yum!

  112. Wow, a new pie recipe to try and a chance to win a Kitchenaid mixer! Can’t wait to try the Candy pie. . I like alot of different pies… so today I will go with pumpkin pie with coconut in the batter and nuts in the crust. It’s divine!

  113. Christina M

    I love tried and true pumpkin pie. And I would LOVE a Kitchenaid. I’ve been dreaming of one for about five years but it’s always out of my budget so thanks for the chance to win one 😀

  114. Care

    Well my favorite pie has got to be any pie my Grandma makes. On Thanksgiving she made 8 different pies. She’s 94 years old and she’s been making pies since she was 13 so she seriously does make the best pie ever! I’ve tried making pies using her recipes and they never turn out as good as hers and she told me I need more practice and I need a kitchen aid mixer lol she’s had her kitchen aid mixer for over 20 years! Thanks for this great giveaway!

  115. Lindsay

    It’s a pie tie for me! I cannot choose between my grandma’s famous fudge pie and a delicious cinnamon stresual apple pie. Both make my mouth water just thinking about them!

  116. Donna

    My mom’s coconut pie…the one she makes without a recipe…no matter how much I watch or try and measure it is just not the same…so it is best made by her.

  117. BEST GIVEAWAY EVER!!! My favorite pie? I’d have to say apple–but then again, I love any kind of apple dessert, and I know I will LOVE making them all with a new Kitchenaid! 🙂

  118. Nichole

    I’m a pudding person, but have never made homemade pudding so I’m pretty tempted to try this.

    But my favorite pie is pumpkin, hands down. Maybe because I only let it happen once a year so it keeps it exciting and I can’t get sick of it.

  119. Patsy S

    My favorite pie…coconut custard! Yummy Yummy!!! Easy, quick and delicious!!! We made some at our church baking ministry and I bought one! Wrong decision…I ate too much of it!!!

  120. LeAnn H.

    this pie looks incredible!! cant wait to try it i just tried buttermilk pie and I’m in love with it but i added nutella and chopped almonds!! so good

  121. KellyR

    My favorite is pumpkin pie, but it’s also my downfall since I’m the only one in the house who eats it. My husband and daughter LOVE Pudding Pie though, so we tend to have that one more often.

  122. My fave pie has got to be a double crust apple pie with homemade caramel sauce on top, my grammy knows how to bake! But after reading this candy pie recipe, I may have a new front runner for after apple season!

  123. Mindi Dagerman

    I love homemade pumpkin pie, but only with real pumpkin! 🙂 It is delicious. My hubby makes a delicious homemade whipped cream too.

  124. Heather H

    I love apple pie…and pumpkin pie too. I would love to win a new mixer! The 4-1/2 qt is too small for all the cooking & baking I do these days.

  125. tina loreto

    I have to say my favorite pie would be chocolate pudding icebox pie… grahm crakers stuffed with choco puffing and topped with cool whip and chocolate shavings…yummo

  126. evelyn

    Love pecan pie and since we have been buying our dark syrup from The WEBstaurant store it has been so much better!! Everyone at Thanksgiving said the pies were so much better. Thank you WEBstaurant store for all our supplies. I will be trying this recipe tomorrow thank you for sharing!

  127. Oooh! What a fantastic giveaway! My 40+ year old one finally whipped it’s last mashed potatoes last Thanksgiving and I’ve been saving up (very slowly) for another one. I really hope I win this! That would be SO AMAZING!!!

    My favorite pie is pumpkin pie. I think I could live on it if they let me … lol. Thanks so much for this chance to win! I hope I win! I hope I win! I hope I win!

    Hugs,
    Snoopy 😀

    stampinsnoopy at gmail dot com

  128. Kellie

    My favorite pie has to be Lemon Meringue. I’ve tried to make it a few times, but can’t get it to stop sweating…any suggestions?!?

  129. Lucy

    that looks absolutely evil!!!! I’m not really that much of a pie fan, but my favorite type would have to be cherry with a crumble top. I will mercilessly pick off every bit of buttery crumb off the top and then leave MOST of the sweet fruity filling for someone else to finish off.

  130. Brandon W.

    My favorite pie is definitely my Gran-dad’s chocolate meringue pie!
    His filling is so rich, and the meringue is super fluffy and light! Perfect!!

  131. Sue smith

    My favorite pie would have to be Amelia Mud Pie. Oreo crust with chocolate ice-cream, whipped cream, ground coffee, brandy, kaluha and topped with chocolate fudge topping.
    TO.DIE.FOR!!!!
    I’ve always wanted a nice Kitchen Aid mixer, so that would be cool to win one.
    Hope everyone has a wonderful Holiday coming up!

  132. Wendy Christie

    My favorite “pie” is a Reese’s cheesecake pie topped with chocolate ganache, an crumbled Reese’s candy on top 😀 I would absolutely love to have this mixer. Mine is on it’s last leg and I bake every week, sometimes 2 to 3 times a week <3

  133. Chrystal Sharp

    My favorite pie would be coconut cream pie. I have fond memories of it. When I was a little girl I would have a slice and we would talk about everything. Now anytime I need to talk we go to the bakery and we have a slice of pie.

  134. Mary Mom

    My all time favorite is apple pie made with fresh apples from the orchard in the fall. This year I rendered leaf lard and made the best crust ever.

  135. Natalie

    I would love to share the recipe that I made for apple pie on Thanksgiving this year, but I pretty much made it up. 🙂 What’s funny is that my brother in law has not stopped talking about it. He says that he usually doesn’t eat apple pie, but this was the most amazing apple pie he had ever had and couldn’t stop eating it. 🙂
    Made my day!

  136. Chuck

    Do people really have just one favorite pie? I like pecan pie and apple pie. Dang, I’m going to have to try making a pecan-apple pie now.

  137. Heidi Reed

    I don’t usually like pie, but if it’s the only thing around I like Banana cream with nilla wafer crust, or chocolate cream with oreo crust.

  138. My favorite pie? Just about any pie, but maybe strawberry,or pecan? Or maybe this new one? I like pies so much that as a child I asked for a birthday pie instead of a cake! neldacnm at yahoo

  139. Jami

    I SO need that kitchenaid! Anyways, I have a dreamy pie for you. It’s called a Cheese Pie, however, my entire in-law family is disgusted by the thought of trying it so I renamed it Cinnamon Pie. Let me know if you’re interested in the recipe!

  140. claire

    im not sure i have a favorite but i did just make a healthyish pumpkin pie, i made the no bake recipe and portioned personal dishes and i didn’t do a crust so even better!

  141. Jill

    My family’s all time favorite pie has to be my Peanut Butter Pie! But I have to admit, once I make the candy pie you posted, we might have a new favorite!

  142. Karen L

    My DH made me a creme brulee pie this summer, it was heaven. That would be my favorite for now, before that it was strawberry rhubarb.

    Thanks for the contest. I just found you and subscribed. I agree about homemade pudding.

  143. Cara

    Love apple and berry pies – and you blog. We have been really enjoying the rice crispy treats (we have several g-free family member:)

  144. Crystal

    I am not a pie person either. I made myself some pumpkin cupcakes with pumpkin buttercream (recipe from iambaker) on Thursday. I also made a Kentucky Pie (it’s got a lil bit of bourbon) for everyone else on Thanksgiving. I did have one piece of that. It has just enough chocolate in it to tempt me.

  145. Dani

    First I want to say that I love, love, love your blog. You make the most interesting and delicious creations. I have tried many and they have been well received at every party.

    My favorite pie has to be pumpkin pie. Typically Thanksgiving is the only time I eat pie unless there is some sort of mousse pie in front of me!

    Happy Holidays 😉

  146. Jen Kim

    Mmm~ The candy pie looks so delicious~ My favorite pie is pumpkin pie, but I think this candy pie is going to become the family favorite~ =P

  147. Amanda Mendenhall

    My favorite pie would have to be pumpkin, or banana cream! 🙂 LOVE the candy pie though!! Mmmm who doesn’t like candy & pie?

  148. Jennifer

    I LOVE pie!! I even eat it for breakfast sometimes. I favorite has to be cherry raspberry and the crust has to be home made of course!!